Debt Consolidation vs. Debt Settlement: Key Differences

When comparing debt consolidation vs. debt settlement, the right choice depends on your financial situation. Debt consolidation combines multiple debts into a single payment and may help preserve your credit, while debt settlement involves negotiating to pay less than you owe and often comes with more significant credit consequences.

Factors such as your credit score, income, debt load and ability to keep up with payments can all influence which option makes the most sense. Here's what you need to know before deciding.

MoneyLion offers a service to help you find personal loan offers. Based on the information you provide, you can get matched with offers for up to $100,000 from our top providers. You can compare rates, terms, and fees from different lenders and choose the best offer for you.

Key Takeaways

• Debt consolidation combines multiple debts into one payment and helps preserve your credit, while debt settlement negotiates to reduce what you owe but causes serious credit damage. The right choice depends largely on your credit score, income and how far behind you are on payments.

• Debt consolidation is the better option for most borrowers. It pays debts in full, keeps accounts in good standing and can improve your credit over time with consistent payments.

• Debt settlement should be a last resort. Missed payments, delinquent accounts and a settled-for-less notation can stay on your credit report for up to seven years, making future borrowing harder and more expensive.

• Forgiven debt over $600 may be treated as taxable income by the IRS. This is an often-overlooked cost of debt settlement that can result in an unexpected tax bill at year end.

Summary generated by AI, verified by MoneyLion editors

Debt Consolidation vs. Debt Settlement: At a Glance 

Here's how debt consolidation and debt settlement differ in terms of repayment, credit impact, costs and overall risk.

What Is Debt Consolidation? 

• Debt consolidation is when a borrower wants to lump multiple debts into one payment.

• It’s typically for those who have a good credit score.

• You can do a balance transfer to a 0% credit card, take out a personal consolidation loan or home equity loan, or enroll in a DMP.

• Credit may dip temporarily, but in the long term your credit will improve provided you make consistent payments.

What Is Debt Settlement? 

• Debt settlement is when you or a debt settlement company negotiates with creditors to accept less than the amount you owe.

• You typically pay a lump sum, and any debt forgiven — over $600 — is treated as taxable income.

How Each Option Works

Debt consolidation and debt settlement aren’t complicated in how they work. Here’s a step-by-step guide on what to do. 

How Debt Consolidation Works 

1. Review your current debts, interest rates and income to determine which debt consolidation option will work best for you. 

2. Choose between a balance transfer card, a personal debt consolidation loan or a debt management plan (DMP).

3. Pay off your original creditors based on your method. With a personal loan, the lender sends a lump sum to your account or pays creditors directly. With a balance transfer card, you move old balances to the new card. With a debt management plan, the agency negotiates a lower APR and distributes your payments.

4. Depending on the method you choose, you make one single payment until you pay off the full balance. 

How Debt Settlement Works 

1. You stop making payments to your creditors. 

2. You contact a debt settlement company to negotiate on your behalf or you contact the creditors directly. 

3. Make sure the accounts are delinquent, since this creates an incentive for creditors to work with you.

4. The settlement company negotiates a lump sum offer for less than the full amount that you owe.

5. Review and approve each settlement. The fee is charged only after the deal is accepted. 

6. You’ll repeat with each creditor until the debt is settled. 

Debt Consolidation vs. Debt Settlement: Which Costs Less?

Your credit score, debt amount and your APR determine which option costs less.

• Debt settlement may look like it costs less in the short term, but in the long term, this method may cost you more because of the damage to your credit. 

• Debt consolidation that uses a balance transfer card may be the cheapest of all options. You transfer the balance and earn 0% interest for 12 to 21 months.

• Debt consolidation with a DMP costs $25 to $50 a month plus whatever balance is negotiated with the nonprofit credit counseling agency. 

How Each Option Affects Your Credit

When Debt Consolidation Makes Sense 

• Your credit score is good to exceptional.

• You have a steady income. 

• You have multiple debts you want to consolidate into one payment.

• You can realistically pay off the debt within the loan term or promotional period.

• You’ve identified spending habits that will prevent you from running up debt in the future.

When Debt Settlement Makes Sense 

• You’re already delinquent on several debts.

• You have poor credit.

• You can’t afford any of the other options. 

• You’ve weighed the long-term impact on your credit.

• You have lump sum funds to settle the debt.

Alternatives to Debt Consolidation and Debt Settlement 

If you think debt consolidation or debt settlement isn’t  the right option for you, consider these alternatives: 

• Debt snowball: You pay the minimum on every balance, and then anything extra is dedicated to paying off the smallest balance.  

• Debt avalanche: You pay the minimum on every balance, and anything extra is paid on the highest interest balance — regardless of the amount. 

• Bankruptcy: You can file a Chapter 7 or Chapter 13 bankruptcy. With a Chapter 7, you opt to totally discharge your debts, while in a Chapter 13, you establish a repayment plan, and upon completion your debts are discharged. 

Which Debt Relief Option Should You Choose? 

Choose Consolidation If:

• Your credit score is good to excellent and you want to pay your debt in full.

• You have multiple debts and you want to have a single payment. 

• You want to preserve your credit.

Consider Settlement If:

• Your debt load is unmanageable and your accounts are already delinquent.

• You’ve exhausted all other options and don’t want to file bankruptcy.

• You’ve weighed the negative implications for your credit. 

Talk to a Nonprofit Credit Counselor If:

• You’re unclear on which option is best for you.

• You’re behind on payments but not quite delinquent. 

FAQs

Is debt settlement the same as debt consolidation? 

Debt settlement isn’t the same as debt consolidation. With debt settlement, you pay an amount that’s less than what you owe. In debt consolidation, you consolidate the full amount of your debt into one payment. 

Is debt consolidation better than debt settlement? 

For most borrowers, debt consolidation is better than debt settlement. You pay the full amount of what you owe, you protect your credit and you pay far less in fees. 

Does debt settlement hurt your credit? 

Yes, debt settlement will hurt your credit since you stop payments to your creditors. Also, your credit report will indicate you’ve “settled for less than the amount of what you owe.” 

Does debt consolidation hurt your credit? 

Debt consolidation will hurt your credit temporarily since there’s a hard inquiry on your credit. However, in the long term, your credit may improve if you continue to make consistent payments over a period of time. 

Can you settle debt yourself? 

Yes, you can call your creditors directly and settle the debt yourself. You don’t have to use a debt settlement company to settle your debt. 

Is forgiven debt taxable? 

If your debt is over $600, the IRS will treat this amount as ordinary taxable income. You’ll be taxed on that amount. 

Which option pays off debt faster? 

Debt consolidation is faster since the payment timeline is two to seven years. Debt settlement isn’t a guarantee to pay off debt since creditors may refuse to settle, and the payment timeline can last longer. 

Key Terms

• Debt consolidation: The process of combining multiple debts into a single loan or payment, ideally at a lower interest rate. It pays balances in full and can improve your credit score over time with consistent on-time payments.

• Debt settlement: A process where a third-party company or the borrower directly negotiates with creditors to accept a lump-sum payment for less than the full amount owed. It reduces principal but causes significant credit damage and may result in a tax liability on forgiven amounts.

• DMP: A structured repayment arrangement set up through a nonprofit credit counseling agency. It negotiates lower interest rates with creditors and consolidates payments without requiring good credit to qualify.

• Credit utilization ratio: The percentage of available revolving credit currently in use. Paying off credit card balances through debt consolidation can significantly lower this ratio and improve your credit score.

• Chapter 13 bankruptcy: A form of personal bankruptcy that allows borrowers with steady income to keep assets while repaying debts through a court-approved plan over three to five years. It is one alternative to consider when both consolidation and settlement are not viable options.

Summary generated by AI, verified by MoneyLion editors

Sources

• Federal Trade Commission. "How To Get Out of Debt."

• MyCreditUnion.gov. "Debt Consolidation Options."

• Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. 2023 "What do I need to know about consolidating my credit card debt?"

• Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. 2024. "What is the difference between credit counseling and debt settlement, debt consolidation, or credit repair?"

• Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. 2023. "What is a debt relief program and how do I know if I should use one?"

Photo credit: Anchiy / iStock