Can Paying Off Credit Card Debt Temporarily Lower Your Credit Score?

Can paying off credit card debt hurt your credit score? It can, and it can feel confusing: You’re doing the responsible thing by eliminating your outstanding balances, so why did your credit score stall or even go down? 

If this happens to you, don’t fret. Depending on how your debt was paid off, this could be an expected result, and it doesn’t mean it will last. We’ll cover when paying off credit card debt can decrease your score, when it can help your score and why it’s usually the right move even if there’s a temporary dip.

MoneyLion offers a service to help you find personal loan offers. Based on the information you provide, you can get matched with offers for up to $100,000 from our top providers. You can compare rates, terms, and fees from different lenders and choose the best offer for you.

Key Takeaways

• Can paying off debt hurt your credit score? Yes — but usually only briefly: Any dip is typically short-lived and almost never means paying off what you owed was a mistake.

• The effect depends on the type of debt: Paying off revolving debt like a credit card usually helps your score, while paying off an installment loan like a personal loan can cause a small, temporary dip.

• Watch what happens when you close a card: Paying off a card lowers your credit utilization, but closing it shrinks your available credit and can push utilization back up — and closing an older account can reduce your average account age.

• Credit mix is a minor factor: Paying off a loan can ding your credit mix, but that's only about 10% of your FICO score, compared with 30% for amounts owed — so it's never a reason to stay in debt.

• Recovery is usually fast: Scores often rebound within one to two months after you pay off revolving debt, the time it takes lower balances to be reported to the bureaus.

• Keep doing the fundamentals: Pay on time, keep utilization below 30% and monitor your credit report for reporting delays or errors that could distort your score.

Summary generated by AI, verified by MoneyLion editors

Can Paying Off Debt Hurt Your Credit Score? 

Paying off debt can lower your credit score temporarily, but this isn’t always the case. The effect on your credit score depends on the type of debt you’re paying off: revolving debt like a credit card, or installment debt like a personal loan. 

Beyond that, knowing what affects your credit score goes a long way in determining which direction things may go. 

Why Paying Off Credit Card Debt Usually Helps

To understand why a credit score goes up and down in relation to debt payments, consider your credit utilization rate, one of the most important factors in determining your score. Having a lower credit utilization rate means your debt is low relative to the amount of credit available to you, and this can improve your credit score.

But the relationship between paying off credit cards and credit utilization can cut both ways. When you pay off debt, you’re freeing up more of your credit line, which will improve your credit utilization ratio. But if you close the credit card after paying off that debt, you’ll also have less credit available to you overall, which could damage your overall credit utilization. 

Another factor in how credit scores are calculated is the average age of your accounts, with older accounts being an advantage, so closing an older account could drop your score in this way as well. You don’t necessarily have to close a credit card account after paying off your debt, though, so this is often avoidable. 

The main thing to remember is that, unlike other debts, such as installment loans, paying off credit card balances is generally a positive move for your overall financial health and credit score in the long run.

Why Paying Off Debt Can Sometimes Cause a Temporary Drop 

Many people wonder, “Why did my credit score drop after paying off a loan?” If you’ve just started researching how to get out of credit card debt, this may seem like a cruel trick. But the good news is that it’s usually nothing to worry about.

Some people may see a temporary drop in their credit score after payoff if the debt they’re resolving is from an installment loan. Credit mix is a factor in your credit score, and when you pay off a personal loan, it no longer contributes to your credit mix. 

However, it’s worth noting that credit mix accounts for only 10% of your FICO score, compared to credit utilization, which accounts for 30%. So the change to your credit mix isn’t a reason to hold off on paying down loan debt.

Credit Cards vs. Installment Loans: Why the  Difference Matters 

If you pay off debt from a revolving credit line, like a credit card, you’ll probably improve your credit utilization ratio, which is one of the largest factors that impact your score. 

But with installment loans, where you pay the money off in equal monthly chunks, the account closes automatically when it’s fully paid off, so you have no choice in the matter. This could impact your credit mix and slightly decrease your credit score in the short term, even though paying off debt was the right financial decision.

How Long Does the Temporary Dip Usually Last? 

According to Experian, credit scores typically recover within one to two months after paying off revolving debt, such as a credit card balance. That’s enough time for your lower revolving credit balances to be reported to the credit bureaus and positively impact your credit utilization.

For installment debt like a personal loan, you could see a credit score dip when you pay it off, but it should bounce back within a few months, provided your finances don’t change in other ways.

Keep in mind that larger increases in your credit score may take longer than a few months, since the most important factors contributing to your score focus on longer-term patterns like payment history and amounts owed.

What Else May Be Affecting the Score at the Same Time 

If there are multiple moving parts in your financial picture around the time you pay off your credit card debt, your credit score may drop due to other reasons. 

For example, if you pay off a credit card account but apply for a new line of credit, your score will dip a few points from the hard credit inquiry, and it could dip further if you accrue a high balance on this new account. Closing another account, such as a credit card you no longer use, could also impact your score in a way that has nothing to do with paying down your debt.

What To Do if Your Score Drops After Paying Off Debt 

If your credit score drops after paying off debt, don’t panic. It’s often an expected result of closing an account or reducing your average account age or credit mix. The temporary dip that you see is not worth staying in debt over, and in the long run, your credit score will recover, all else being equal.

Payment history is the biggest factor in determining your credit score, so continue making all your payments on time, and keep your credit utilization below 30% whenever possible. 

Also, keep a close eye on your credit report in the months after you pay off a debt to check for reporting delays or errors that can result in an inaccurate score.

Bottom Line 

So, can paying off debt hurt your credit score? Counterintuitively, yes, but the effect is usually short-lived, and it almost never means it was a bad idea to pay off what you owed. Keep in mind that it can take a few months for your credit score to recover from a temporary dip in this case, and that making on-time payments and maintaining a lower utilization rate can improve your score in the long run.

FAQ: What Happens to Your Credit Score After Paying Off Credit Card Debt? 

Can paying off debt hurt credit score? 

Paying off debt could hurt your credit score in the short term, depending on the type of debt you’re paying off, but your score should recover in the long run.

Why would my credit score drop after paying off debt? 

Your credit score could drop after you pay off debt if you close an account that was positively contributing to your average age of accounts or your overall credit mix.

How long after paying off debt does your credit improve? 

Your credit score can improve within one to to months after paying off revolving debt, such as credit card debt.

Key Terms

• Credit utilization rate: The share of your available revolving credit you're using. Paying off a card lowers it, but closing the card can raise it again by reducing your total available credit. Experts advise keeping it under 30%.

• Revolving debt: Debt on an open, reusable account like a credit card. Paying it off generally improves your credit utilization and helps your score.

• Installment debt: Debt repaid in fixed monthly amounts, like a personal loan or auto loan. The account closes automatically when paid off, which can slightly affect your credit mix.

• Credit mix: The variety of credit types you hold. It accounts for about 10% of your FICO score, so paying off a loan that narrows your mix has only a minor effect.

• Amounts owed: How much you owe relative to your available credit, the second-largest FICO factor at about 30%. Credit utilization is its biggest driver.

• Average age of accounts: A measure of how long you've held your credit accounts. Closing an older card can lower this average and temporarily reduce your score.

• Hard inquiry: A credit check triggered when you apply for new credit, which can dip your score a few points — one reason a score may fall around the same time you pay off a card.

• Payment history: Whether you've paid past accounts on time. It's the single biggest FICO factor at about 35%, which is why on-time payments matter most over the long run.

Sources

• myFICO: What's in my FICO Scores? 

• CFPB:  Does it hurt my credit to close a credit card? 

• CFPB: How do I get and keep a good credit score? 

• myFICO: Does Closing a Credit Card Boost Your FICO Score? 

Summary generated by AI, verified by MoneyLion editors

Photo credit: BraunS / iStock.com