Should I Pay Off My Mortgage Early?

Few things feel more adult than the idea of owning your home outright. No more monthly payments. No more interest. Just you and your paid-off place. 

But before you yeet your cash into the abyss of early mortgage payments, ask yourself: should I pay off my mortgage early or invest that money instead? The answer isn’t one-size-fits-all. It’s more like… it depends: on your rate, your goals, and your appetite for risk.

Let’s unpack the pros and cons of paying off your mortgage early, when it might make sense to wait, and what actually happens when you kick your lender to the curb.

---

MoneyLion makes it easy to explore personal loan offers that fit your goals. Whether you’re freeing yourself from debt or building wealth elsewhere, we’ve got your back. Based on the information you provide, you can get matched with offers for up to $50,000 from our top providers. You can compare rates, terms, and fees from different lenders and choose the best offer for you.

---

Potential pros of paying off your mortgage early

Should you pay off your mortgage early? Sounds like a dream, but is it financially smart, or just emotionally satisfying? Spoiler: it can be both.

✅ Interest savings 

Every extra payment chips away at the total interest you owe, saving you potentially tens of thousands over the life of the loan. An online mortgage calculator can show you how much you’d save.

✅ Reduced debt-to-income ratio

Paying down your mortgage lowers your debt-to-income ratio, which can improve your credit profile and boost your chances of snagging future loans (think: second home, business venture, or sweet RV).

✅ Guaranteed return

Unlike the stock market, paying off your mortgage gives you a guaranteed return equal to your interest rate. If your mortgage rate is 6%, that’s a risk-free 6% return. Hard to beat in this interest rate environment.

✅ Financial freedom

No mortgage = more monthly breathing room. You could travel, invest, start a business, or just sleep better knowing you don’t owe a dime on your home.

Cons of paying off your mortgage early

Paying off mortgage early? A few concerns might come up after the initial champagne toast. Here are some of the potential disadvantages of paying off mortgage debt:

❎ Opportunity cost

Here’s the flip side. Every dollar thrown at your mortgage is a dollar not invested elsewhere, like in a 401(k) or index fund. Over time, long-term investments may beat the “return” you’d get from early payoff. According to the S&P 500’s historical return (around 10% annually), investing could outperform many mortgage interest rates. Of course, there’s no guarantee of that in any given year, and you could also lose money. But if you have a long time horizon, that 10% average figure might give you some peace of mind. 

❎ Lost tax benefits 

You might kiss the mortgage interest deduction goodbye. While the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 made this perk less useful for many (due to the increased standard deduction), it’s still a factor to weigh.

❎ Liquidity issues

That equity is locked up tighter than your high school diary. If you need quick cash in an emergency, you’ll have to refi, sell, or take out a home equity line of credit — none of which are instant.

❎ Diversification concerns

Sinking all your extra cash into one asset (your home) could leave you less diversified. And as any financial planner will tell you, all eggs + one basket = potential danger.

What to consider before paying off your mortgage early

Ready to take the plunge? Not so fast. Here’s what you need to check first.

Compare interest rates

If your mortgage rate is low (say, under 4%) and your investments could potentially return more (say, 7–10%), then investing might win the math game. This is the classic should I pay off my mortgage or invest debate, and the answer depends on your financial priorities.

Emergency fund status

Do you have 3 to 6 months of expenses saved? If not, pause the early payoff plan. Liquidity matters; your roof can’t cut you a check in a crisis.

Prepayment penalties

Yes, some lenders charge fees for early repayment (rude, but true). Check your loan terms to avoid surprise charges.

Consider other options 

Paying down your mortgage isn’t the only power move. You could:

👉 Refinance your mortgage to lower your rate and monthly payment. 

👉 Invest your extra cash in tax-advantaged accounts or the stock market. 

👉 Split the difference: Pay off mortgage or invest? Actually, why choose? You could do a little of both at once. Pay a little extra on your mortgage payment every month, and invest slowly and steadily while you’re at it. 

What happens when you pay off your mortgage?

Cue the confetti. You’ll receive a mortgage payoff statement, your lender will send you a mortgage satisfaction letter, and the lien on your property will be released. You’re now the sole owner of your home, and no one can take that away. Oh, unless you forget about property taxes

Expect a small potential bump to your credit score (thanks to improved credit utilization), and a new monthly budget that’s suddenly a lot freer.

Is Paying Off Your Mortgage Early Right for You?

There’s no perfect age or magic number, so at what age should you pay off your mortgage? For some, it’s before retirement (freedom!). For others, it’s when their investments start outperforming their debt.

The real answer? When it fits your goals, your wallet, and your risk tolerance.

FAQs