Aldi vs. Costco: Which Is Cheaper for 12 Essentials on a Starter Budget?

Starting out on a tight budget means every dollar has to earn its keep. The same shopping list can cost wildly different amounts depending on where you buy it, and prices shift from store to store like a bad mood.
That’s why Aldi and Costco keep coming up in the “where should I shop?” debate. One is a no-frills discount grocer. The other is a warehouse club that hands you a pallet of paper towels and asks for a membership fee. Both promise bargains, but a low sticker price doesn’t automatically mean cheap groceries.
Check It Out: 7 Name-Brand Items You Should Always Buy at Costco
Sign Up Today: Start Growing Your Net Worth With Smarter Tracking
To settle it, we lined up a dozen everyday essentials side by side, from the fridge to the cleaning aisle, so you don’t have to whip out a calculator in the middle of the store. Keep reading to see which one really deserves your starter-budget loyalty.
Explore More: The Best Costco Buys To Grab Now For Fall
Strawberries
Aldi: $3.09 per pound
Costco: $3.40 per pound
Costco sells a 2-pound container of strawberries for $6.80, or $3.40 per pound. At Aldi, you can get a pound of strawberries for $3.09 and save yourself some money.
Eggs
Aldi: $1.85 per dozen
Costco: $3.00 per dozen
Buying in bulk doesn’t always cost less. A 24-count pack of Kirkland Signature free range large eggs costs $6 at Costco, breaking down to $3 per dozen. Aldi beats this by charging $1.85 for a pack of 12 Goldhen large grade A eggs.
Milk
Aldi: $4.39 per gallon
Costco: $3.36 per gallon
For milk that fits a starter budget, Costco actually beats Aldi prices. One gallon of Friendly Farms 2% reduced fat milk at Aldi costs $1.03 more than a gallon of Kirkland Signature 2% reduced fat milk at Costco.
Boneless Chicken Breasts
Aldi: $3.29 per pound
Costco: $3.39 per pound
This round comes close with only a 10 cent difference between the stores. Even though the Kirkland Signature fresh chicken breasts are only $3.39 per pound at Costco, the Kirkwood chicken breasts are 10 cents less.
However, it’s worth noting that an Aldi package weighs around 2.68 pounds, while a Costco pack is supersized at approximately 6 pounds. So, the one you go for could depend on just how much you need.
Organic Mixed Vegetables
Aldi: $0.19 per ounce
Costco: $0.13 per ounce
A 10-ounce bag of Simply Nature Organic Mixed Vegetables costs $1.89 at Aldi. More for less, you’ll pay $10.20 for a 5-pound bag of Kirkland Signature organic mixed vegetables at Costco.
Ritz Crackers
Aldi: $0.43 per stack
Costco: $0.44 per stack
A staple in many pantries, an 18-stack box of Ritz crackers is on sale for $7.93 at Costco (but regularly costs $11.23 or $0.62 per stack). Aldi also has their box of Ritz crackers fresh stacks discounted to $5.15 or $0.43 per stack (regularly $5.75 or $0.48 per stack). This product's "stack" size is slightly smaller than the Costco option, so keep that in mind when comparing the prices.
In this case, less is more — in your wallet.
Gatorade G Zero
Aldi: $0.66 per 12-ounce bottle
Costco: $0.63 per 12-ounce bottle
At Aldi, an 18-pack of the Gatorade thirst quencher variety pack costs $11.89. The Costco option, a 28-pack of the Gatorade thirst quencher variety pack, is cheaper per ounce and you get an additional 10 bottles.
Honey Nut Cheerios
Aldi: $0.29 per ounce
Costco: $0.18 per ounce
Priced at $4.45 for a 15.4-ounce box, General Mills Honey Nut Cheerios is notably pricier at Aldi. If you shop at Costco, you’ll pay $9.86 for a two-count pack of 27.5-ounce boxes of Honey Nut Cheerios for a total of 55 ounces.
Rao’s Homemade Marinara Sauce
Aldi: $0.35 per ounce
Costco: $0.20 per ounce
No spaghetti dinner is complete without a jar of great sauce. IF you're looking for the best deal, shop at Costco. You can get two 31.7-ounce jars of Rao’s homemade marinara sauce for $12.99, or just 20 cents per ounce. In comparison a smaller, 24-ounce jar of this same Rao’s homemade marinara sauce is $8.29 at Aldi.
Tissues
Aldi: $0.02 per tissue
Costco: $0.02 per tissue
Here we have a stalemate — you’ll pay the same per-tissue cost at each store. A four-pack of Willow ultra soft facial tissues (240 total tissues) costs $4.75 at Aldi. If you opt for Costco, a 12-pack of Kleenex ultra soft facial tissues (1,020 total tissues) is $24.28.
Granola Bars
Aldi: $0.20 each
Costco: $0.18 each
Get a 64-count pack of Kirkland Signature soft & chewy granola bars for $11.34 at Costco. Slightly pricier per bar, an 18-count box of Millville chocolate chip chewy granola bars is $3.65 at Aldi.
Dawn Platinum Powerwash Dish Spray
Aldi: $0.34 per ounce
Costco: $0.23 per ounce
A 16-fluid-ounce bottle of Dawn platinum powerwash dish spray is $5.45 at Aldi. You can save money by opting for the Dawn platinum plus powerwash dish soap spray starter kit — containing 64.5 total fluid ounces for $14.74 at Costco.
The Bottom Line
Costco prices were cheaper on seven of the 12 items listed above, with one product tied for the lowest price. Honestly, this was a close one, but overall Costco had more competitive prices, making it the better choice for a starter budget.
Editor’s note: Prices and availability are subject to change.
This article was provided by MoneyLion.com for informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial, legal or tax advice.

