Auto Insurance Renewal? Call With This 60-Second Script Before You Pay

Auto insurance has to be renewed every year, but that doesn’t mean you have to pay a higher premium each time. Comparing options can help you secure a lower premium, but even before you do that, you may want to negotiate with your current insurer.
Some auto insurance companies give small discounts or opt against raising premiums if you give them a call and explain that you are considering other options. Granted, it’s best to go into this call prepared, and using this simple script can give you a massive advantage.
Find Out: Compare Auto Insurance Rates and See What You Could Save
Explore Now: Low-Interest Credit Card Offers That Fit Your Needs
Starting the Conversation
Start by stating who you are and explain that the premium quote you received is higher than before. Then bring up any leverage points, such as a good driving history and how many years you have been with the insurer to help move the odds of a lower premium in your favor. Below is a script that does all of that within 30 seconds.
“Hello. I am calling about my upcoming auto insurance renewal. I saw that my premium went up to [amount], and this price does not fit my budget. I have been a customer for [X] years with a clean driving record, and I’d like to see what we can do to lower this rate today before I look at switching providers.”
It’s important to be courteous when delivering this script and remain respectful throughout the call. Those intangibles can increase the likelihood of the representative giving you a better price.
Addressing Objections and Adjusting Your Policy
The representative may dismiss your request by saying that insurance premiums have been increasing statewide. It’s a common objection, but using this script can move the conversation back in your favor:
"I understand market rates are rising, but I've already gotten competing quotes from other insurers for similar coverage that are significantly lower. I'd prefer to stay with you to avoid the hassle of switching. Can you review my account for any available loyalty discounts, low-mileage discounts, or affinity group savings?"
The script lets the representative know that you are actively considering other options and may move quickly if there is not a solution. The final detail about reviewing your account gives the representative some wiggle room to help secure lower premiums without giving you a special deal.
In addition, a lower premium can be created by increasing the deductible, updating annual mileage, removing unnecessary add-ons or bundling auto insurance with other policies.
Lower Payments: Auto Loan Refinance Options That Could Help Ease Your Budget
See How: Student Loan Refinance Options That Could Help You Save
Confirm That You Will Receive a Lower Premium
It’s possible for the conversation to quickly move in your favor the moment you ask for a lower rate, but some haggling may need to happen along with some changes to your policy, such as increasing your deductible.
But don't just say yes to the first lower number. Instead, attempt to get an even lower premium by using this script: “If we apply these updates and discounts, what is the absolute lowest monthly total you can get me to today? If that gets us close to [Target Amount], I'm ready to lock it in right now.”
This question gives a target that will free up some space in your monthly budget. The representative may also get creative and suggest some different ways to reduce your premium payments.
You can then use this script to verify that you will get a lower premium:
“I just wanted to verify quickly. After all of these changes, I will end up with a premium of [amount]. Is that right? When will I see it show up in my dashboard?”
It’s good to clear up any confusion before the phone call ends. However, if the representative says that you will see the price soon, you can thank the representative and wish them a good day.
This article was provided for informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial, legal or tax advice.