MoneyLion
Oct 29, 2026

Erin Moriarity: How Social Security Payroll Tax Works and What Happens If It's Cut

The financial expert breaks down the confusing world of when you do and don't owe tax on Social Security benefits.
Written by J. Arky
|
Erin Moriarity: How Social Security Payroll Tax Works and What Happens If It's Cut

You may or may not be aware that Social Security in America comes with a payroll tax, but it’s important to know some basics about how it works. It’s equally vital to understand what happens if lawmakers remove it and how it affects you.

While the bipartisan proposal to remove the income cap calls it a “no-brainer” move to fix funding for Social Security, financial influencer Erin Moriarity said this is only a partial fix for Social Security's deficit. In fact, she said that high-earning, self-employed workers could see a marginal tax rate increase of over 50%.

Be Aware: 3 Overlooked Social Security Rules That Could Add Thousands to Your Retirement Income

WHop On: How Middle-Class Earners Are Quietly Becoming Millionaires — and How You Can, Too

She broke it down on her channel Erin Talks Money — here’s what you need focus on.

Boiling it down to the essential issue: right now, someone earning $90,000 annually would be taxed 100% for Social Security while someone else making $350,000 would only pay taxes on the first $184,500, which is the limit for this kind of taxation. Moriarity cited in her video that 65% of Democrats, as well as 62% of Republicans, are in favor of removing this cap.

According to Moriarity, eliminating the cap is estimated to close a 75-year funding gap in Social Security funding between 40% and 60%. However, to fully fix the shortfall in funding, a measure would have to take place immediately to raise taxes from 12.4% to roughly 16.8%, which Moriarity said is about 4.25 additional percentage points.

However, she also said that increasing tax rates and increasing tax collections do not often move in one syncopated motion, but happen independent of each other over time.

“If the income gap is eliminated, but we don’t subsequently adjust the formula on how benefits are paid, ultimately higher income earners would receive higher benefit payouts,” said Moriarity, adding that what American taxpayers put into Social Security, they are eventually paid out for in retirement.

All U.S. citizens who pay more today into the benefit would put financial strain on future taxpayers to keep up the pace of revenue for generations to come. As birthrates drop and Americans live longer lives, there are few Americans paying into Social Security while those who use these benefits are needing them for longer periods of time. This ultimately means that higher earning Americans would need to pay more in marginal rates to get Social Security fully funded for years to come, particularly the self-employed.

Removing the payroll tax cap, according to Moriarity, would address the Social Security shortfall in funding and help reduce the already existing gap in the program. On the other hand, she said that it would increase marginal tax rates for high earners, such as the freelancers, contractors or small-business owners who are responsible to pay for all of their taxed earnings.

Ultimately, removing this cap on payroll tax could fundamentally change what Social Security was designed for in the first place — to give older Americans a financial safehold as they age.

This article was provided by MoneyLion.com for informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial, legal or tax advice.

More From MoneyLion:


J. Arky
Written by
J. Arky
J. Arky has over two decades of experience working with online publications, blogs, and media outlets as a seasoned finance writer in the SEO space. He has been covering personal finance, economics, consumer trends, business practices, and retirement related topics for a variety of sites since 2022. Three out of 15 of the top articles for GOBankingRates — including the most viewed piece of January 2025 — were all written by Arky. He has spent his career specializing in the financial and legal sectors within the scope of his writing, including projects for MoneyLion, GOBankingRates, Money Digest, and GoSifter. Arky has had works published by So Say We All Press, including the literary journal Black Candies.
Brendan McGinley
Edited by
Brendan McGinley
Brendan McGinley is a New York-based editor and writer.