Freezing Your Home in Winter To Save on Heating Bills — Is It Worth It Financially?

The average household spends $1,196 between November and March to heat their home with electricity, which 43% of the country does, according to the Energy Information Administration (EIA). The average price for the 46% who use natural gas is $640. For the much smaller percentage who still rely on heating oil, the cost of staying warm in winter has soared to $2,115.
Faced with such daunting utility bills, the temptation to dial back the thermostat is stronger than ever and there’s a logical argument for doing so — but only modestly and strategically. The trend toward forgoing heat altogether, riding out the winter and entering spring with four-figure savings, is fatally flawed — literally, if it gets cold enough to kill and financially, even if you can endure the freeze.
Read Next: ChatGPT’s 5 Tips to Lower Your Winter Heating Bill
Sign Up Today: Start Growing Your Net Worth With Smarter Tracking
The following article outlines why freezing is a terrible idea for your home and finances, why enduring some discomfort might pay off, and how to audit your bills to avoid both while still lowering costs.
Savings Are Hiding in Your Thermostat
According to the U.S. Department of Energy, the typical household can save up to 10% on winter heating bills by turning down the thermostat while sleeping or away from home. Average savings are roughly 1% for each degree you lower the temperature.
Based on the EIA averages, that equals the following savings.
Electricity: $120
Gas: $64
Oil: $212
The Potential Cost of Freezing for Financial Gain
You can save a few hundred bucks in the coldest months by turning down the heat when you least need it. However, going without heat altogether means enduring months of extreme discomfort in many climates and risks costly repairs that can easily outweigh any energy savings.
For example, Angi (Formerly Angie’s List) quoted the typical price range for fixing burst pipes at between $200 and $3,000, with an average of $500.
Audit — and Potentially Argue — Your Bills
Utility Explained outlined a four-step process to audit your utility bills line by line so you can start saving without freezing.
Step 1: Analyze the bill summary to confirm the billing scope, including the statement cycle, service plan and payments made or credits received.
Step 2: Verify the meter reading or other usage record.
Step 3: Document every charge, including consumption, supply or delivery fees, riders, taxes, public charges and one-time items.
Step 4: Compare your current bill to a prior one.
Utilities often conceal price increases with the following common charges, which can add up to three figures.
Customer charges
Delivery charges
Minimum delivery charges
Supply charges
Taxes and fees
Next, Ask Questions To Complete the Audit
The next step is to contact your provider for answers to the following questions.
Which tariff and service class apply?
How was billed usage calculated?
Is the reading estimated, actual, corrected, estimated or customer-submitted?
Why did certain line items change from a prior bill?
What riders, taxes, credits and one-time charges are included?
What’s the review process if calculations appear incorrect?
How To Dispute Charges
Utility Explained offers a full tutorial on how to dispute incorrect charges on a bill successfully.
The correct order of communications is as follows:
Call first.
Submit a written complaint next.
File a complaint with your state public utilities commission.
Escalate to small claims court or through the FTC if no action is taken.
Your Action Letter Will Make or Break Your Case
The platform offered the following verbatim sample written request template.
"Dear Customer Service Department:
I am writing to dispute a charge on my [electric/gas/water] bill dated [bill date] for account number [account number] at [service address].
The charge in question is [describe the specific charge, e.g., “$XX for usage on line item YY”]. I believe this charge is incorrect because [explain why — e.g., “my meter reading shows XX kWh, not the YY kWh billed” or “I already paid this amount on [date] per confirmation number [number]”].
I have attached [list attached evidence — e.g., “a photo of my meter dated [date], a copy of my prior bill and my payment confirmation”].
I request that you [state the resolution you want — e.g., “correct the bill to reflect my actual meter reading and issue a credit for the overcharge”].
Please respond in writing within 15 business days. You can reach me at [phone number] or [email].
Thank you for your attention to this matter."
This article was provided by MoneyLion.com for informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial, legal or tax advice.
More From MoneyLion:

