MoneyLion
Nov 15, 2026

Group Gifting vs. Buy Now, Pay Later: Find Out Which Way Makes More Sense To Divide a Gift Purchase

With the pressure of the holidays, the right spending approach can protect your budget.
|
Edited by Zuri Anderson
Group Gifting vs. Buy Now, Pay Later: Find Out Which Way Makes More Sense To Divide a Gift Purchase

People are getting creative with their gift-giving strategies as inflation pushes Americans to tighten their wallets and rethink spending habits. According to a survey from The Penny Hoarder, 77% of respondents plan to change how they give gifts because of rising costs, including buying fewer presents or opting for less expensive ones.

Meanwhile, some Gen Zers are teaming up with friends, partners or siblings to chip in for one larger present rather, and others are turning to buy now, pay later (BNPL) services to spread out the cost into smaller payments.

Pressure, Prices and Presents: Your Guide To Ease Spending Stress This Holiday Season

Begin Your Journey: Start Growing Your Net Worth With Smarter Tracking

But which approach makes more financial sense?

Group gifting involves pooling money with others to purchase a shared present. Each person contributes an agreed-upon amount, allowing the group to buy a gift that might otherwise be too expensive for one person.

Buy now, pay later lets shoppers get an item upfront and repay the cost in installments. Some plans are interest-free, while others charge interest or fees, depending on the provider and repayment terms.

“With buy now, pay later, you can buy or gift the item immediately while committing to pay it off within the contract timeline,” said Melanie Musson, a retail finance expert with Quote.com. “Group gifting may require more patience, but it can help people share the cost without one person taking on debt to cover the purchase.”

Giving a good gift feels nice, but it can drain your budget. Splitting the cost of a gift can be easier on your finances.

However, consider this: Imagine four friends want to buy a $600 gift together. With group gifting, each person would contribute $150, assuming they split the cost equally. No one person has to cover the full price.

“But, if someone doesn't pay, the person who used BNPL is on the hook for the full amount because they put their name on the line,” Musson said. “If the purchaser receives only $450 in reimbursements, they would still need to cover the remaining $150, plus any applicable interest or fees.”

Both options have potential downsides, so looking at the pitfalls is important before swiping your credit card or sending cash for your part of a present.

BNPL can be enticing, but it can make a purchase seem more affordable than it really is, particularly when there’s interest or fees that pile on the cost of the item. Missed payments can also make a purchase more expensive, but many people turn to BNPL options.

According to a Gallup 2026 survey, 37% of people in low-income households (those earning less than $48,000) rely on BNPL options for online purchases, compared with 21% of people in high-income households.

“The biggest danger of buy now, pay later is that it puts your finances backward and enables you to easily spend money you don't have,” Musson explained.

However, going in on a group gift can create pressure to spend more than you can afford, especially when friends or family members have different budgets. Musson cautions against shelling out more than your budget allows to appear generous or avoid awkwardness.

Sticking to a price you can reasonably spend on a gift looking carefully at the cons of BNPL and group giving is key before choosing a payment option. If the group's spending limit doesn't work for you, exploring other options might be the way to go.

BNPL may work for someone who can manage the repayment schedule independently, without relying on reimbursements, and pay off the balance according to the plan's terms.

But if neither option fits your finances, consider choosing a less expensive gift instead.

“It's better to buy what you can afford than to buy something and hope to pay for it later,” Musson said.

Ultimately, the best method is the one that lets you celebrate someone without creating financial stress for yourself or anyone else.

Editor’s note: Prices and availability are subject to change.

This article was provided by MoneyLion.com for informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial, legal or tax advice.

More From MoneyLion:


Heather Altamirano
Written by
Heather Altamirano
Heather Altamirano is a versatile and seasoned writer who joined GOBankingRates in 2024, bringing with her two decades of journalism experience. Throughout her career, she has focused on helping consumers navigate key financial topics, including retirement planning, budgeting, saving and debt management, aiming to empower individuals to achieve financial independence. Heather's work has been featured in prominent outlets, including NASDAQ and Yahoo Finance, and she holds a Bachelor’s degree in Broadcast Journalism from the University of Southern California (USC).
Edited by
Zuri Anderson
Zuri is an editor with over 8 years of digital content and news experience. When she's not managing her freelance writers, voraciously editing copy and coming up with engaging stories, she's catching up on her favorite shows, books, movies and video games.