We Asked an Insurance Broker Whether Suze Orman’s $10M Early Retirement Number Holds Up

Financial guru Suze Orman once told Paula Pant on the “Afford Anything” podcast that she advocates saving at least $5 million to retire early. That’s a lot of zeroes, and enough to make anyone with a 401(k) feel years behind.
But is that realistic or even necessary? We asked an insurance broker who specializes in retirement income. The short answer: Your number depends on how long you’ll be retired and what you’ll spend, not what your neighbors saved. Run the math, and that eye-watering figure looks less like a plan and more like a scare tactic.
Be Aware: 7 Keys To Funding Early Retirement Before Touching Your 401(k)
For You: 14 Subtly Genius Things All Wealthy People Do With Their Money — That You Should Do, Too
What Orman Says You Need
In Episode #153 of the “Afford Anything” podcast, Orman told Pant and her listeners that $2 million is insufficient to retire early on, calling it “pennies in today’s world.”
When asked what a safe amount would be, she said it depends on where you live, what you spend and whether you own your home outright. According to her, you’d need $5 million, or closer to $10 million, to retire early.
At $10 million, Orman said, you could pull about $350,000 a year after taxes without touching your principal. That covers regular living expenses ($100,000 a year) and full-time caregiving for a disabled family member ($250,000 a year).
Without naming Orman, MoneyLion asked Jason Gerstenberger, an independent insurance broker whose firm, Jason Gerstenberger Insurance, specializes in retirement income, to weigh in. We wanted to know how much someone would need to retire earlier than the current median retirement age of 62, per the Transamerica Center for Retirement Studies.
Real Fear, Unrealistic Price Tag
The fear behind Orman’s warning is real. But Gerstenberger said $100,000 in income plus $250,000 in annual caregiving costs doesn’t describe “anything close to a real retirement.”
He argued that Orman is “describing self-insuring for every single catastrophic event simultaneously with cash.” Almost nobody does that, he said, including wealthy people.
The bigger picture backs him up. Nearly two-thirds of retirees live on less than $100,000 a year, according to Gerstenberger.
Insurance Beats Self-Insuring
Gerstenberger agreed early retirees need to plan for decades of expenses. Where he differs is on catastrophic costs.
Insurance handles those for far less than it would cost to cover them out of your own pocket. With homeowners, health and long-term-care coverage in place, you get the protection Orman describes for a “tiny fraction” of what self-insuring would cost.
How Much Other People Have Saved
Empower personal dashboard data from March shows that the median retirement savings for people in their 20s is $43,875. That means half have more and half have less. Here’s how the median climbs by age group:
Age Group | Median Retirement Savings |
|---|---|
30s | $98,952 |
40s | $220,919 |
50s | $460,363 |
60s | $568,116 |
These figures can either lull you into complacency or spark unnecessary panic. It's important to remember that your early-retirement target has nothing to do with what other people have saved.
What Your Number Actually Depends On
Your number depends on two things: how many years you’ll spend in retirement and how much you’ll spend each year.
Fidelity recommends saving 33x your annual expenses for a retirement lasting 40 years or more. That should allow you to withdraw 3% per year.
Three points to remember:
You can’t draw from your retirement accounts until age 59.5.
Social Security will provide some of your income beginning as early as age 62.
You won’t need private health insurance after age 65, when Medicare begins, but you’ll still pay premiums and have out-of-pocket costs.
Online retirement calculators can help you model different scenarios and set a monthly savings goal. A fee-based financial advisor can do the same with more nuance.
“If that required monthly number is impossible to save, the honest fix is moving the retirement date or the expenses, but never anticipating unrealistic returns to close the gap,” Gerstenberger said.
Keeping Your Early-Retire
ment Plan on Track
Gerstenberger offered these tips to give yourself the best chance of hitting your early-retirement goals.
Track one month of real spending. Build your income needs from what your life costs today, not what you hope it will cost.
Buy disability insurance. It protects your current income and your ability to keep saving. The 25th Annual Transamerica Retirement Survey found that 52% of retirees retired earlier than expected, and 40% of them cited health reasons.
Get health insurance quotes for your target retirement age. Skip this and you’ll likely underestimate healthcare costs.
The Bottom Line
Orman’s $10 million is a dramatic way to make a real point: Retirement is expensive, and risk is unforgiving. But the number that matters is yours.
“The people who retire well aren’t the ones who timed the market perfectly,” Gerstenberger said. “They’re the ones who knew their expenses, covered the fixed ones with guaranteed income and insured the risks that they couldn’t absorb.”
This article was provided by MoneyLion.com for informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial, legal or tax advice.
More From MoneyLion:
How Middle-Class Earners Are Quietly Becoming Millionaires — and How You Can, Too
Mark Cuban's $14,600 Case for Skipping Daily Coffee in Favor of Investing
Claiming Social Security at Age 70 Boosts Your Check 24%—But There's a Big Catch
Discover a Smarter Way to Keep Unexpected Expenses From Derailing Your Budget

