Is It Really Better To Keep Savings Than Pay Off Credit Card Debt? Reddit Users Debate
On the r/personalfinance Reddit thread, a user asked for help deciding whether they should wipe out their savings account to pay down their $1,500 credit card debt.
The 45 replies, while full of advice, often contradicted each other. So, what’s a borrower to do?
Read Next: 18 Ways To Tackle Your Budget and Manage Your Debt
For You: 8 Low-Effort Ways to Make Passive Income (You Can Start This Week)
The Interest Argument
Many commenters urged the original poster (OP) to pay down the debt for one simple reason.
“You're spending more on interest than you're earning in the savings account,” one commenter summarized.
Another wrote, “Wiping out debt should always take priority.”
And another: “Having money sitting on a credit card is an emergency.”
Savings accounts often pay 0.01% to 4% interest, while credit cards typically charge 16% to 26% interest. Yet as stark as that math looks, it’s not the only factor in the equation.
Cash Gives You Control
Credit consultant Ali Zane of Imax Credit Repair pointed out that having savings offers something unique: ownership to use any time without having to ask permission.
“Liquidating your savings and paying off the card means giving up the last unconditional asset you've got," Zane said.
Card companies can freeze your credit, cut down your card limit or reduce your cash advance access. And it just gets worse from there, as you look at options like selling stocks or bonds prematurely, or spending thousands on closing costs to borrow a second mortgage or HELOC.
You need cash because you maintain full control over it. No one can (legally) take it from you or deny you access.
Safety Nets Are Important
Cash doesn’t just provide practical benefits. It also allows you to make emotionally difficult — but important — decisions.
“Having nothing in savings affects how we feel about our security and safety in the world,” said financial coach AJ Schneider of Beyond The Green Coaching. “People stay in terrible situations because they don't have the cash to help them leave a job or bad relationship.”
In other words, cash grants you the freedom to change your circumstances.
Consider Credit Scoring
Zane added that most people have a misconception about the credit impact of paying your cards off entirely.
“A $0 balance can cause your credit score to drop 5 to 15 points," Zane said. "Modern scoring algorithms prefer balances of 1% to 9% to $0 on a card as it suggests that you pay timely.”
The Root of the Problem
The real question for many Redditors came down to the root cause of the credit card debt. One put it like this: “You need to address your spending habits first, or you'll just end up right back where you are now, but with your savings wiped out.”
The first step is to stop accumulating credit card debt. Consider locking your credit card away in a drawer and deleting it from all your online accounts. Then, find a 0% interest introductory card offer, transfer your balance to it and aggressively pay down the balance. It'll take some time, but eventually, you'll be debt-free.
In the meantime, build your emergency fund to cover at least two to three months of living expenses. That safety net will help you survive life’s many surprises and give you the freedom to make the best long-term decisions.
This article was provided by MoneyLion.com for informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial, legal or tax advice.
More From MoneyLion: