7 Stocking Stuffers From Old Navy They'll Love
Finding the right stocking stuffer is an art. The gift must fit inside a stocking hung by the chimney (or wherever) with care, but it should also deliver big value in terms of practicality, fun factor and, of course, price. To find well-made stocking stuffers your loved ones will actually use — without turning your budget into a lump of coal — you’ve got to shop at Old Navy.
Old Navy offers a variety of options that are as cost-effective as they are chic, all guaranteed to bring joy to your loved ones. There’s something for every age and demographic. So, let’s go dashing through the snow to Old Navy to find some perfect stocking stuffers.
1. Faux-Fur Fingerless Gloves for Women: $11.99
As the song goes, “Baby, it’s cold outside.” But texts still need to be sent, and style standards must be upheld. This pair of faux-fur fingerless gloves lets the fashionista in your life do both, all while remaining cruelty-free to animals and kind to your budget. Available in pink, taupe, white and black, this extra-warm set is designed to fit all sizes.
2. Wide-Cuff Ribbed Beanie for Men: $4.50
All too often, hats are considered afterthoughts of winter wear. This wide-cuff ribbed beanie protects your favorite person’s noggin from the cold while blending effortlessly with the rest of their winter gear. The beanie comes in a variety of colors — including teal, gold, orange and cherry — to brighten even the bleakest winter night.
As part of a special Old Navy sale, this beanie is currently priced under $5. Check online or contact your local store if you’re shopping outside of the sale dates.
For You: Holiday Shopping: 15 Hacks To Get More for Less
Explore More: Meet Your Complete Financial Toolkit. Budget, Build Credit, And Track Your Money - All In One Place
3. High-Waisted Fleece-Lined Ankle Leggings: $8.99
You may need to do a little maneuvering to fit these high-waisted, fleece-lined ankle leggings into a stocking, but it will be worth it. Extra-warm and extra-sporty, they’re ideal for someone who’s just as likely to head out for a winter run (to each their own) as they are to spend the day running errands. The leggings are available in regular, tall and petite sizes, as well as XS through 4X.
4. Gender-Neutral Go-Warm Microfleece Gloves for Kids: $3
These warm and durable microfleece gloves aren’t just a win for kids — parents will appreciate having an extra pair on hand, given children’s penchant for losing them. Available in black, pink, light gray and off-white, they’re both practical and affordable.
5. Flannel Scarf: $6
The flannel scarf is practically a stocking stuffer staple — and for good reason. This option is as versatile as it is practical, keeping loved ones warm on even the most blustery winter days, whether they’re dressed casually for errands or heading out to a holiday soiree or game night. It’s available in classic camel, black or fiery red.
This price reflects a special Old Navy sale, so check online or call your local store if you’re shopping outside of the sale window.
6. Crew Socks 6-Pack for Toddler & Baby: $7.19
If someone in your circle is celebrating their very first Christmas, these adorable crew socks help kick off the season in style. Featuring cartoon tiger, panda or owl eyes alongside classic stripes, they’re a fun and practical gift. They’ll also save parents a little money — after all, little ones seem to grow out of clothes overnight.
7. Old Navy x Disney Gender-Neutral Snug-Fit Graphic Pajama Set for Kids: $14.80
Do the kids in your life love Lilo & Stitch? Does ‘ohana mean family? Yes, and yes. Show you’ve been paying attention by gifting this Lilo & Stitch-themed pajama set, complete with a festive holiday pattern. Stitch and Christmas lights? That’s a guaranteed win on Christmas Day.
Wrapping It Up
Choosing the right stocking stuffers can help ensure your loved ones enjoy a happier, healthier and flat-out more fun new year. When you shop at Old Navy, you’ll find fashion-forward pieces at great prices — just be sure to shop within the sales window for select items.
Editor’s note: Pricing and availability may vary. Prices are accurate as of Dec. 16, 2025.
Need a little extra holiday magic in your budget? MoneyLion is giving away $2,000 a day through Jan. 24. Sign up and see if this festive windfall lands under your tree.
This article was provided by MoneyLion.com for informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial, legal or tax advice.
More From MoneyLion: