MoneyLion
Nov 10, 2026

Promotion Without a Raise? Learn How To Ask for the Pay To Match

Two-thirds of U.S. professionals say they’ve taken on bigger jobs without a meaningful raise to match.
Written by Vance Cariaga
|
Edited by Ashleigh Ray
Promotion Without a Raise? Learn How To Ask for the Pay To Match

Getting a job promotion is exciting, but the luster can fade in a hurry if you don’t get a decent bump in pay along with it. Unfortunately, that happens a lot these days.

More than two-thirds (68%) of U.S. professionals recently surveyed by Benedictine University report getting more job responsibility or a better title without a meaningful pay raise. Promotions without raises might look nice on paper, but they won’t help you pay the bills or attain more financial security.

Explore More: 25 Money-Making Side Gigs That Don't Require a 9-to-5 Job

Get Started: 10 Low-Effort Ways To Make Passive Income (You Can Start This Week)

Keep reading to find out how to turn that title into a bigger paycheck.

Benedictine University polled more than 500 employed U.S. professionals about career advancement and found a growing number of workers getting “dry” promotions: more responsibility or a better title, with little or no pay increase.

The problem hits some groups harder than others. Gen Z professionals reported the highest rate at 75%, followed by millennials at 68% and Gen X at 61%. By industry, healthcare led at 78%, followed by information technology at 77%, finance at 66% and education at 63%.

Other highlights from the survey include the following:

  • Nearly nine in 10 (87%) professionals would prefer higher pay even if their responsibilities stay the same.

  • More than half (54%) wanted a better title or greater responsibility, while 43% hoped to move into leadership or management positions.

  • About two-thirds (63%) want to advance within their current workplace. In this case, employers would be more likely to retain them if they offered higher pay (81% of respondents), a clear path to promotion (37%) and more flexible work options (37%).

The fastest way to command a bigger salary is to expand your skill set and marketability. One of the best ways to do that is to further your training and education.

Two-thirds (66%) of the professionals Benedictine surveyed saw an online graduate degree as a smart strategic move, whether they wanted to climb within their current company, switch fields or simply stay competitive.

Cost matters, though. Seventy percent said they’d pursue a degree if it could pay for itself within three years, and 29% said employer tuition assistance would push them from thinking about a graduate degree to actually enrolling.

Once you’ve been offered a promotion, the real work begins. Indeed recommends two strategies for negotiating the pay that should come with it.

  • Know your market worth. Research what people in your new role typically earn. Talk to colleagues in your field, ask mentors for salary estimates and search online salary data. Showing your employer the going rate gives you a strong starting point.

  • Emphasize your skills and value. Explain why you deserve more. Point to the extra responsibilities and hours you’re taking on, highlight results from past projects and cite praise from clients, managers or colleagues. If you’ve driven revenue or new business in previous roles, put a number on it.

Your new title is a bargaining chip, so spend it. Walk into that conversation with salary data, a list of what you’ve accomplished and the new responsibilities you’re prepared to take on. Ask for a number that fits the job you’re stepping into, not the one you’re leaving.

The worst outcome is a polite no, and you’ll have learned exactly where you stand. Staying quiet is the costly move, because every paycheck you accept without asking is one you can’t get back.

This article was provided by MoneyLion.com for informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial, legal or tax advice.

More From MoneyLion:


Vance Cariaga
Written by
Vance Cariaga
Vance previously worked as a reporter/editor with Investor's Business Daily, the Charlotte Business Journal, the Charlotte Observer and other publications. His debut novel, "Voodoo Hideaway," was published in 2021.
Ashleigh Ray
Edited by
Ashleigh Ray
Ashleigh is an editor specializing in personal finance and banking content, with four years of experience — first at GOBankingRates, then at MoneyLion — turning complex financial topics into advice readers can actually understand and use. She holds an MFA in Creative Writing from the University of South Florida and brings that same care for clarity and voice to every piece she edits. She's based in Tampa, Florida.