4 Property Tax Mistakes Costing Homeowners Over 55 Thousands a Year

All homeowners in the United States pay property taxes, but you’ll pay a much lower rate in some states (Hawaii, Alabama) than others (New Jersey, Illinois), according to the Tax Foundation.
In nearly all cases, the amount you pay is based on the assessed value of your home. Avoiding mistakes can help you save a lot of money — something that takes on added importance as you get older and find your budget tightening up.
Keep Learning: 2 Ways Downsizing Can Lower Your Property Taxes (And When It Can't)
Try This: How Middle-Class Earners Are Quietly Becoming Millionaires — and How You Can, Too
Here are four property tax mistakes 55-and-older homeowners make that can cost thousands of dollars a year.
1. Misjudging a Home’s Assessed Value After Downsizing
This mistake often happens when older homeowners decide to downsize to a smaller house without consulting a realtor, according to Chad Cummings, attorney and certified public accountant (CPA) at Cummings & Cummings Law, who previously worked in finance and tax.
“I see Florida retirees buy a smaller home after reviewing the seller’s tax bill by checking the county assessors website [and] don't want to shell out for a real estate agent,” Cummings told MoneyLion.
The mistake is thinking that a tax bill is always the best way to assess a home’s value and property tax liability.
In Florida, for example, the tax bill often reflects the seller’s capped “Save Our Homes” (SOH) assessment rather than the buyer’s future assessment. The SOH is a property tax law that limits how much the taxable value of a permanent residence can increase each year. You can transfer up to $500,000 of your accumulated SOH tax savings from your old home to your new one, which is known as “portability.”
“Florida reassesses after the sale, although a qualifying owner can port up to $500,000 of assessment difference,” Cummings said. “Missing portability on a $700,000 home can add $4,000 to $8,000 annually [to property taxs]. Misunderstanding portability is the No. 1 problem and is usually avoidable by working with a pro.”
2. Not Accounting for Tax Hikes After Downsizing
This mistake is similar to misreading a home’s assessed value. As an example, Cummings pointed to Texas, which has “eye-wateringly high” property taxes.
“The 10% homestead appraisal cap in Texas does not preserve the seller’s assessment for the buyer, and it does not limit tax-rate increases,” Cummings said. “A home moving from a $300,000 capped value to a $500,000 market appraisal after purchase can add about $4,000 annually at a 2% combined [property tax] rate.”
3. Missing Appeal Deadlines
If you file an appeal to challenge your property tax assessment, you’ll likely face a strict deadline. Missing the deadline could mean forfeiting your right to challenge a property’s assessment for that year – and missing a chance to lower your annual bill by hundreds or even thousands of dollars.
The deadline varies depending on where you live. For example, in Illinois it’s typically 30 days from the notice date of assessment or a decision from a lower level of review, according to a blog from BMI Bornstein LLC, a provider of property tax and legal services.
To avoid this mistake, BMI Bornstein recommends subscribing to assessor calendars or hiring counsel who can monitor deadlines.
4. Not Applying for Age-Based Relief
Some states offer eligible seniors age-based relief programs that can lower their property taxes by up to thousands of dollars a year. But many homeowners are not aware of the program.
“This is a very practical tool that even many CFPs and CPAs miss,” Cummings said. “In 2026, a Florida owner age 65 or older with 2025 household income no greater than $38,686 may qualify for a locally adopted exemption of up to $50,000. Texas owners age 65 or older may claim an additional $60,000 school exemption and a school-tax ceiling. Missed applications or incorrect records can waste hundreds or thousands each year.”
This article was provided by MoneyLion.com for informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial, legal or tax advice.
More From MoneyLion:
