The Social Security Tax Mistake Retirees on Reddit Want To Warn Others About (And an Expert's Take)

Social Security benefits may be taxable, but federal income tax isn’t automatically withheld from benefit checks. This is something new claimants may not realize until they receive an unexpected tax bill.
One retiree recently warned others about exactly that in a Reddit post. Here’s the Social Security tax mistake to be aware of, and what experts had to say.
Check Out: How Much Can I Earn in 2026 and Still Collect Social Security?
Read Next: 8 Clever Ways Retirees Are Earning Up to $1K Per Month From Home
The Social Security Tax Mistake One Redditor Flagged
In a Reddit thread, one user was asking other retirees about the Social Security application process. One commenter offered a piece of advice: “Don’t forget to take federal tax out! I set mine for 10%.”
They explained that income from sources such as traditional IRAs, 401(k) accounts and capital gains can affect whether Social Security benefits are taxable. Not all states tax Social Security income, but federal income tax may apply to your benefits.
“People assume Social Security works like their old paycheck did – taxes just come out, done. It doesn't work that way,” said Leandre Boone, founder of Buckeye Financial.
According to the Social Security Administration (SSA), up to 85% of your benefits are taxable if you file a return as an individual and your combined income exceeds $25,000, or if you file a joint return and you and your spouse have a combined income of more than $32,000.
And it’s up to 85% of benefits, not an 85% tax rate.
“We do have to explain to some clients how it's not 85% tax rate, but rather 85% of their Social Security income included in their taxable income and then taxed at their marginal income tax rate,” added Caleb Moyer, owner of Moyer Tax Services, an Omaha, Nebraska-based tax preparation firm.
What Happens If You Don’t Withhold Enough?
When you don’t withhold enough, one of two things can happen: “A big check written at tax time, or an underpayment penalty stacked on top. Neither is fun,” Boone explained.
But Moyer also tells his clients that withholding doesn’t have to come from one specific source. For example, someone receiving Social Security along with a pension or retirement account distributions may choose to have more taxes withheld from those sources instead.
This can provide more flexibility since Social Security only allows federal withholding at set rates of 7%, 10%, 12% or 22%, Moyer explained. So someone could have no federal tax withheld from Social Security yet still have enough withheld elsewhere to cover the overall tax liability.
The important thing is to make sure enough is paid throughout the year.
“If your income puts your benefits in taxable territory and you skip setting up withholding, you're racking up a tax bill all year without knowing it,” Boone noted. “Then April hits and it's a gut punch.”
How To Avoid a Surprise Tax Bill
If you prefer to withhold directly from your benefits, Boone said that you can do so by filing Form W-4V, Voluntary Withholding Request, with the SSA.
“You pick a percentage: 7, 10, 12 or 22. It comes out of your benefit gradually instead of hitting all at once,” he explained. You can do this through quarterly estimated payments.
“Either route, the real move is doing the math before the benefits start – not guessing, actually figuring out how much of your income will be taxable and picking a number that covers it,” Boone advised.
And as Moyer mentioned previously, you can also choose to have more withheld from other income sources.
“Ultimately, the goal is to pay in enough throughout the year to avoid 'tipping' the government by having to pay more in taxes because of interest or penalties,” Moyer stated.
This article was provided by MoneyLion.com for informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial, legal or tax advice.
More From MoneyLion:
13 Subtly Genius Things All Wealthy People Do With Their Money — That You Should Do, Too
You Can Retire Now If You Answer 'Yes' to These 6 Questions, According to Kevin Lum
I'm a Financial Planner: Cut These 7 Hidden Expenses To Save Hundreds a Month
Discover a Smarter Way to Keep Unexpected Expenses From Derailing Your Budget
