Target vs. Old Navy: Which Store Has Cheaper Wardrobe Basics?

Nobody has ever gotten excited about restocking their T-shirt drawer. Basics are the unglamorous backbone of a closet: the tee you throw on with everything, the layer that bridges chilly mornings and warm afternoons, the leggings that work at the gym and on the couch. They’re also the pieces you replace most often, which makes their price tags matter more than you’d think.
If you’re refreshing your wardrobe this season, it’s worth shopping around before these staples hit your cart. Target and Old Navy both sell near-identical versions of the classics, so we lined up four of them side by side to see where your money goes furthest.
Good To Know: 3 Items You Should Always Buy at Target Instead of Dollar Tree
Be Savvy: 9 Low-Risk Accounts Proven To Grow Your Money Up to 13x Faster
Think of it as a closet audit with a price-tag twist. Grab a coffee, pull up both websites and let’s see whether the bargain hunt actually pays off.
Check It Out: 8 Old Navy Fall Deals To Grab as Soon as Possible
Basic Crew-Neck T-Shirt
Basic T-shirts are nice to have to wear alone or as a layering piece. And if you can find them for under $10, you can stock up affordably.
Target's A New Day perfect t-shirt costs $8. It features a crew neckline, short sleeves and a relaxed fit. It’s made with a cotton-modal jersey blend and comes in six colors, including black, white, navy, clay red, olive green and cream striped.
Old Navy's EveryWear crew-neck t-shirt has a regular price of $14.99. The relaxed-fit shirt is made from 100% cotton and is available in regular, petite and tall sizing. It’s also available in 17 solid colors and six prints.
At their regular prices, Target saves shoppers $6.99 when compared to Old Navy.
Ribbed Tank Top
Tanks earn their keep under cardigans, over long-sleeve tees or solo with lightweight shorts when it’s warm out.
Target's A New Day slim fit ribbed tank top costs $8. It’s made of a cotton-modal-spandex blend and comes in seven solid colors and two striped versions.
Old Navy's First-Layer Ribbed Scoop-Neck Tank Top fitted tank is made from a blend of cotton, recycled polyester and spandex and is offered in regular, petite and tall sizes. It has a regular price of $12.99, making it $4.99 more than Target's option.
Everyday Leggings
Leggings are the ultimate crossover piece: gym-ready on Monday, couch-ready on Sunday and easy to pair with an oversized sweatshirt or denim button-up.
Target's A New Day super soft leggings are ankle-length and made with polyester and spandex. They feature a mid-rise waist and a wide elastic waistband. Regularly priced at $12, these leggings only come in black.
Old Navy's high-waisted layering leggings are also ankle-length but have a regular price of $16.99, meaning you'll pay an extra $4.99 than you would at Target. They’re available in regular, petite and tall inseams in a variety of colors and prints.
Button-Front Cardigan
When the temperature drops, a cardigan is the layer you can shed by lunch and pull back on by dusk.
Target's Universal Thread iconic cotton cardigan comes in five colors, including oatmeal, brown and purple, and runs $35. Made of 100% cotton shaker fabric, it features a crew neckline, button-front design, long sleeves and a classic fit.
Old Navy's SoSoft cropped crew-neck cardigan features a button front, crew neckline and relaxed fit, with a regular price of $39.99. Instead of being 100% cotton, it’s a blend of cotton, recycled polyester, nylon and spandex. It’s available in regular, petite and tall fits.
Again, Target beats out Old Navy by $4.99.
So, Which Store Is Cheaper?
Target total: $63.00
Old Navy total: $84.96
Total saved by shopping at Target: $21.96
Target’s regular prices run about 26% lower across all four pieces. Old Navy’s edge is range: petite, tall and regular sizing, plus more colors and prints. It also runs sales often enough to bring its prices close to Target’s everyday pricing, so timing matters.
Restock the basics, skip the markup and save the splurge for another day.
Editor’s note: Prices and availability are subject to change.
This article was provided by MoneyLion.com for informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial, legal or tax advice.
More From MoneyLion:

