I Asked Tax Experts When Roth Conversions Stop Making Sense — Here’s the Answer

A Roth conversion can be a smart move for retirement planning — pay taxes now, enjoy tax-free income later. However, depending on your income, age and timing, converting too much or at the wrong time can actually backfire.
I asked tax experts to explain exactly when Roth conversions stop making financial sense.
Good To Know: 6 Reasons To Think Twice Before Converting to a Roth IRA
Get Started Today: 5 Low-Risk Accounts Proven To Grow Your Money Up to 13x Faster
What a Roth Conversion Actually Does
A Roth conversion shifts retirement savings from future taxable income to tax-free growth, but it comes with an immediate tax bill, according to Paul Gaudio, certified financial planner (CFP) and director of Crestwood Advisors Group LLC.
Generally speaking, a Roth conversion is considered a financial success “when the taxes paid on the conversion are less than the taxes that would have been collected later," added Scott Maurer, certified IRA services professional (CISP) with Advanta IRA.
When Roth Conversions Usually Work Best
The conversion strategy tends to work best during lower-income windows when taxes are temporarily reduced and there’s time for long-term growth, Gaudio said, such as early retirement, before Social Security or required minimum distributions begin.
This can give retirees a few years when their taxable income is lower, which may be a good time to convert part of their money, added Andrew Gosselin, certified public accountant (CPA) and senior contributor at Save My Cent.
"[When] there are still a significant number of years for the investments in the account to grow," the success compounds, Maurer said.
When Roth Conversions Stop Making Sense
A Roth conversion stops being beneficial when the taxes you pay now become higher than the benefits you may have later, Gosselin said.
Conversions trigger immediate taxes, thus Roth conversions tend to stop being beneficial, “when the individual does not have enough money in liquid accessible non-retirement accounts to cover the tax liability of their conversion,” Gaudio explained.
Retirees who have to withdraw extra money from their IRA just to pay the taxes lose the benefit of it, Gosselin said.
When Conversions Push You Into Higher Taxes or Medicare Costs
Converting too much money in a single year can also trigger unintended consequences, such as pushing you into a higher tax bracket, increasing your taxes, raising your Medicare premiums or even reducing other tax benefits, Gosselin explained.
Gaudio said the tax bracket you’re in makes a difference: “If we expect the client to be in the 24% tax bracket throughout their retirement, then we probably would not recommend a conversion amount that puts them into the 32% tax bracket.”
He also noted that it’s important to factor in the potential for increased Medicare premiums by paying attention to the IRMAA brackets.
When You Don’t Have Time for the Strategy To Work
The true benefits of Roth conversions are realized by compounding tax-free growth, Gaudio said. In other words, “the more time you can give your Roth IRA to grow and compound, the better.”
Thus, Maurer pointed out, Roth conversions late in life may yield less tax benefit “because there may not be as many years for the IRA investments to create returns.”
When You’ll Need the Money Too Soon
Conversions can backfire, Gaudio said, especially “when the spending goals of the individual makes it likely that they will need to access much of their Roth IRA funds to support future living expenses.”
The IRS has a rule that states funds converted can only be withdrawn tax-free five years from Jan. 1 of the year of conversion. So this, too, must play into conversion strategizing, Gaudio said.
The Biggest Roth Conversion Mistake To Avoid
Trying to convert too much at once is one of the most common and costly errors.
“People often think they need to convert a large amount all at once, while in reality, it is usually better to do smaller conversions over a few years,” Gosselin said.
A Roth conversion can be a powerful tool but only under the right conditions.
Editor’s note: Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Always consider your individual circumstances and consult with a qualified financial advisor before making investment decisions.
This article was provided by MoneyLion.com for informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial, legal or tax advice.
More From MoneyLion:
How Middle-Class Earners Are Quietly Becoming Millionaires — and How You Can, Too
Mark Cuban's $14,600 Case for Skipping Daily Coffee in Favor of Investing
Claiming Social Security at Age 70 Boosts Your Check 24%—But There's a Big Catch
Discover a Smarter Way to Keep Unexpected Expenses From Derailing Your Budget