Why Does My Debit Card Keep Getting Hacked? How To Stop It

If your debit card keeps getting hacked, there's likely an underlying issue that hasn't been resolved. You may be repeatedly using the same compromised ATM, shopping with a merchant that experienced a data breach, or reusing your card information across multiple websites. This guide explains why it keeps happening and what you can do to stop it.

MoneyLion offers a service to help you find personal loan offers. Based on the information you provide, you can get matched with offers for up to $100,000 from our top providers. You can compare rates, terms and fees from different lenders and choose the best offer for you.

Key Takeaways

• Repeat debit card fraud usually means the source was never removed. A new card won't help if you keep using the same skimmed ATM, breached merchant or infected device.

• Trace the pattern before you request another replacement. List every merchant, ATM and site from each incident and look for the common thread.

• Report debit fraud within two business days to cap your liability at $50. Wait past two days and you could owe up to $500, or the full amount after 60 days.

• Use a virtual card number online and your physical card in person. Matching the replacement to how you were compromised is one of the most effective fixes.

• Update recurring subscriptions the moment your card number changes. Otherwise payments tied to the old number keep exposing you or get declined.

Summary generated by AI, verified by MoneyLion editors

Why Does This Keep Happening?

If your debit card has been compromised more than once, the issue is often tied to the same habits, devices or places you continue to use. Here are some of the most common reasons it might keep happening.

• A merchant you use experienced a data breach.

• You’re entering your card information on a device infected with malware or impacted by phishing.

• You’ve saved your debit card across multiple sites and one has been compromised.

• Your debit card number was exposed in a data breach and is being used for online purchases.

• You're using a replacement card but haven't changed the habits, devices or locations that led to the original compromise.

Skimming

• A hidden device can be attached to an ATM, gas pump or other terminal that captures your magnetic stripe data and PIN as you’re using it.

Card Cloning

• Your card is copied onto a new blank card that can be presented to an ATM or in-person vendors.

Card-Not-Present Fraud

• Your card number is leaked and so allows unauthorized use for online and phone purchases without presenting your physical card.

Saved Card Info on a Breached Merchant Site

• The retailer or vendor has a data breach and your saved card information is vulnerable to attackers and fraudsters. If that sounds familiar, it may also help to review how to avoid online fraud before saving your card on another site.

Recurring Subscriptions Tied to a Compromised Card

• You’ve forgotten to unlink a compromised card to a recurring subscription so the number continues to generate charges.

Debit vs. Credit: Why the Damage Can Feel Different

Debit card fraud and credit card fraud don't affect you the same way. With debit card fraud, your money may leave your account immediately, while credit card fraud generally doesn't tie up your own funds during the investigation. Here's how the protections compare.

How To Trace Where the Leak Is Coming From

Finding the source of the compromise isn't always easy, but you can consider these steps:

1. Review every fraud incident: Don’t just look at the most recent unauthorized transaction.

2. Track where you've used your debit card: For every incident, make a list of every merchant, ATM and vendor where you used your card.

3. Look for patterns: If the same merchant, ATM or vendor appears before multiple incidents, investigate this location more closely.

4. Check for data breaches: Find out if any of the merchants or vendors you’ve used recently have experienced a data breach.

5. Separate your online and in-person purchases: Determine if the unauthorized use was with a physical card or your debit card number.

6. Test your theory: If you suspect a particular source, stop using your debit card there and monitor your account to see whether the unauthorized activity stops.

7. Report suspected skimming: If you believe an ATM, gas pump or other card reader has been tampered with, report it to the business and local law enforcement.

What To Do After Repeat Hacks

If your card keeps getting compromised, you should take a few calculated steps. Here’s what you should do:

1. Report the fraud immediately: To get maximum protection, report the unauthorized transaction within two days and learn how to dispute a debit card charge if you need your bank to investigate.

2. Request a new card and account, if necessary: Reach out to the company that issued your card and request a new card. If fraud continues, consider getting a new bank account.

3. Review the instances of fraud before your new card comes: Look for common instances of ATMs, retailers, etc. to notice any patterns. Ask your bank if they can trace the source of the leak.

4. Avoid using your card at the suspected location: If you know the source of the original hack, do not use your new card at the same place.

5. Once you receive your new card, audit recurring charges: Make sure you link recurring subscriptions to your new card number.

6. Monitor your card: Review your new card statement regularly to make sure the hack has stopped.

Good To Know: Virtual Card Number vs. New Physical Card

The type of replacement you need depends on how your card information was compromised.

• If your fraud occurred in-person, it may be best to get a new physical card.

• If it happened online, a virtual number may provide better protection.

If you’re unsure of where the compromise occurred, consider requesting both a new physical card and a virtual card number.

Breaking the Cycle

Replacing your card is only part of the solution. To reduce the risk of repeated fraud, make these habits part of your routine:

• Identify the source of the unauthorized transaction before asking for a new card.

• Use a virtual card number for online purchases and your physical card for in-person transactions whenever possible, especially if you’re rethinking when not to use a debit card.

• After replacing your card, manually update any accounts that were linked to your old card or card number.

• Monitor your statements and accounts regularly to make sure the charges align with your spending.

FAQs

Why does my debit card keep getting hacked even after I got a new one?

You likely haven’t found the cause of the underlying issue. If you keep using the same compromised ATM, for instance, a new card isn’t necessarily going to protect you from ongoing fraud.

Is my debit card less safe than a credit card?

Debit cards and credit cards both offer fraud protections, but debit card fraud can have a more immediate impact on your finances. Because debit card purchases come directly out of your bank account, delayed reporting can increase your liability from $50 to $500 after two business days.

How do I figure out which merchant or ATM keeps compromising my card?

Review your statements to look for a pattern. Ask yourself if it happened at the same ATM, the retailer you frequent or the gas station you use.

Should I switch to a virtual card number?

If your fraud happened online, it may be a good idea to switch to a virtual number. A virtual card generally masks your real account number.

What happens to my subscriptions when my debit card number changes?

Payments tied to the old card will be declined until you update the card on file, which can interrupt the service. If you’re still in the middle of cleanup, it may also help to read about canceling a lost or stolen debit card so nothing stays tied to the old number.

Can I get my money back if my debit card is hacked multiple times?

Yes, you may be able to get your money back if you report within the appropriate time frames. Typically, you should report within two days and no later than 60 days.

Key Terms

• Skimming: A hidden device attached to an ATM, gas pump or terminal that captures your card's magnetic-stripe data and PIN as you use it.

• Card cloning: Copying your stolen card data onto a blank card that can then be used at an ATM or in person.

• Card-not-present fraud: Unauthorized use of your card number for online or phone purchases without the physical card, common after a data breach.

• Virtual card number: A unique, disposable number linked to your real account that masks it during online purchases, limiting exposure if a site is breached.

• Regulation E: The federal rule that sets debit card fraud liability limits and requires banks to investigate disputes and issue provisional credit within set timeframes.

• Provisional credit: A temporary refund a bank issues while it investigates a fraud claim, generally within 10 business days if the review runs long.

Summary generated by AI, verified by MoneyLion editors

Sources

• Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. "Beware of ATM, Debit and Credit Card ‘Skimming’ Schemes."

• Michigan Department of Health and Human Services. "EBT Card Skimming and Cloning."

• Michigan Department of Health and Human Services. "Credit Card v Debit Card - Know the Difference."

• Office of the Comptroller of the Currency. "Credit Card and Debit Card Fraud."

Photo credit: fizkes / iStock