Payday Loan vs. Personal Loan: What's the Difference and Which Costs Less?

A payday loan is a high-cost option for borrowing money that you're required to pay back by your next paycheck, while a personal loan is a lower-APR option for borrowing money over a longer payback period. Payday loans have virtually no credit score requirements, which can make them more accessible to those who need money in a pinch, but personal loans almost always are the safer and more affordable option.

MoneyLion offers a service to help you find personal loan offers. Based on the information you provide, you can get matched with offers for up to $50,000 from our top providers. You can compare rates, terms, and fees from different lenders and choose the best offer for you.

Payday Loan vs Personal Loan Side-by-Side

Not only are payday loans and personal loans offered for different amounts of money, but they are also structured quite differently. With a payday loan, you'll need to repay the funds you borrow by your paycheck, or you'll incur extra rollover fees. With personal loans, repayment terms range from six months to as long as seven years, depending on the lender, your application and the amount of money you're borrowing. 

Another key difference is the interest rate you'll pay. Payday loan APRs are often north of 300%, whereas personal loan APRs usually max out at 36%. 

How Much Does a Payday Loan Cost vs. a Personal Loan?

Annual percentage rate (APR) refers to the amount you’ll pay in interest to borrow money, plus any additional fees. 

With payday loans, you're borrowing money for a matter of weeks, not months or years, and payday lenders often charge $10 to $30 for every $300 you borrow. That can annualize into a 400% APR, even if you're only paying less than $100 in fees on top of the loan principal. On the other hand, personal loans charge an interest rate over time, and they often come with a separate origination fee of 1% to 10% of the loan amount.

Example: How Fees and Repayment Works on Personal Loans vs. Payday Loans

Say you need to borrow $500. You take out a payday loan that charges a $75 fee, so your total repayment due by your next paycheck is $575. If you repay it in time, it’s a done deal, but if you have to push back the repayment, you’ll be hit with a rollover fee of another $75. 

By contrast, maybe you decide to take out a $500 personal loan with a 20% APR and a 12-month term. After factoring in a 5% origination fee — about $25 — you'd make monthly payments of around $46 and pay roughly $55 in total interest, bringing your all-in cost to about $80 over the year. That's comparable to the payday loan fee, but spread across 12 months instead of two weeks.

Ultimately, APR alone doesn't tell the full story. The true cost of borrowing depends on both the rate and how long you're carrying the debt. A payday loan's triple-digit APR can be manageable if you repay it quickly, but incredibly expensive if you roll it over. A personal loan's lower APR compounds over months or years, so the longer your term, the more you'll pay in total interest.

Should You Pay Off a Loan All at Once or Over Time?

With a payday loan, you'll need to repay the entire amount you borrowed, plus fees, as a lump sum once you receive your next paycheck. If you can, great.

If you can't, you'll have to roll over your payment, which means you'll be charged an additional fee, usually the same amount you paid to borrow money originally. For example, if you borrowed $500 and were charged a $75 fee, rolling over the loan once means you've now paid $150 in fees and still owe the original $500. 

Another Potential Concern With Payday Loans

Payday lenders usually require you to link your account that receives your paycheck so it can automatically debit the repayment once your check clears.

If you don't have enough money in your account when the lender tries to collect repayment, you could be charged overdraft fees by both the lender and your bank. These snowballing fees are what make payday loans dangerous.

Plus, if you fall far enough behind on repaying a payday loan, the lender can sell your debt to a third-party collections agency, which will continue the effort of trying to secure your repayment. Not only is this stressful, but it also has negative consequences for your credit that can stay on your credit report for a few years.

What To Consider With Personal Loans

While you may end up paying more in interest over time with a personal loan, the benefit is that you repay the funds with fixed monthly payments rather than a lump sum due within just two weeks of originally borrowing the money. This repayment structure is often easier to fit into your budget, so it could lessen the risk of falling behind on payments. 

Plus, with a personal loan, you often have more options even if you're not able to repay the funds in time. Many lenders offer hardship programs, and borrowers who reach out when they realize they can't make a payment may be able to negotiate and get adjusted repayment terms that better fit their current financial situation, though it isn't guaranteed.

That's not to say there's no credit risk with a personal loan — lenders can still transfer your debt to collections if you go long enough without repaying and you don't reach out to the lender to discuss your options.

When Does a Personal Loan Make More Sense Than a Payday Loan?

If you need to borrow money and you're trying to decide between a payday loan and a personal loan, you can use the following guidelines to help narrow down your choice.

Choose a personal loan if:

• You qualify for lower APR.

• You need more than a few hundred dollars.

• You can manage fixed monthly payments.

• You want to build credit.

Only consider a payday loan if:

• It's a true emergency.

• You can repay in full with your next paycheck.

• No lower-cost options are available.

Also keep in mind that payday loans and personal loans aren't your only options. You can also consider the following:

• Credit union payday alternative loans (PALs): PALs are similar to payday loans except they're offered through credit unions and their APRs are capped at 28%, plus an application fee of up to $20.

• Payment plans with providers: If you're considering a loan because you owe, you could also go directly to the source and see if you can negotiate a payment plan that's workable for your budget. For example, if you owe money to a landlord, hospital or utility company, contacting them to negotiate could help resolve a short-term cash flow dilemma.

• Family support: Depending on your relationship with your family, you could also consider asking a relative to lend you money to cover an emergency expense.

• Employer paycheck advance programs: Also called earned wage access programs (EWA), these are options like MoneyLion Instacash® that let you use wages from your paycheck based on eligibility ahead of payday with 0% interest, though keep in mind that this isn't a loan.

Whichever option you choose, prioritize predictable payments, transparent costs and options that support your credit health in the long term. For most, this means avoiding payday loans — the fee cycles are short, but they stack up fast.

The Bottom Line: Payday Loan vs Personal Loan

Payday loans offer quick access to cash, but they come at a steep price, and you’ll need to pay the money back quickly as one lump sum. With personal loans, you'll have more time to repay the funds you borrowed, and you’ll pay a more reasonable interest rate.

Before you decide on the right option for you, compare the total cost, including all fees, and make sure you know exactly how much you’re expected to pay and when.

FAQs

What's the main difference between a payday loan and a personal loan?

The main difference between a payday loan and a personal loan is that payday loans have significantly higher APRs and require repayment in full by your next paycheck, whereas you can repay a personal loan in monthly installments over a longer period of time.

Which loan is more affordable?

Personal loans usually have lower interest rates than payday loans, but the more affordable option depends on how quickly you’re able to repay the loan. You may end up paying less out of pocket with a payday loan if you don’t have to roll over your repayment date.

Can payday loans hurt your credit?

Payday loans can hurt your credit if you don’t repay them and the lender sells your debt to collections. This will result in a negative mark on your credit report, which can damage your credit score and stay on your credit report for a few years.

Sources:

• Federal Trade Commission (FTC). "What To Know About Payday Loans."

• MyCreditUnion.gov. "Payday Alternative Loans."

• National Credit Union Administration (NCUA). 2024. "Permissible Loan Interest Rate Ceiling Extended."