Payday Loan vs. Personal Loan: What's the Difference and Which Costs Less?

The main difference between a payday loan and a personal loan is cost and structure. A payday loan is a small, short-term advance — usually a few hundred dollars — that you repay in one lump sum on your next payday at a triple-digit annual percentage rate (APR). A personal loan is a larger installment loan you repay in fixed monthly payments over one to seven years at a much lower APR.

Personal loans almost always cost less than payday loans. A $500 payday loan with a $75 fee that must be repaid in two weeks will usually cost more than a $500 personal loan at 20% APR, repaid with equal monthly payments over a year, which would cost about $80 in interest and origination fees.

Payday loans really only make sense and are worth it if you can pay back every dime by your next paycheck.

Key Takeaways

• Personal loans usually cost less than payday loans when you need more than a couple of hundred dollars or can't repay within two weeks. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) reports that typical payday loan APRs are near 400%, while the Federal Reserve reports an average personal loan APR of around 12% for a 24-month loan.

• Repayment structure makes the difference. Payday loans demand a lump-sum payoff by your next paycheck or trigger rollover fees, but personal loans spread fixed monthly payments over six months to seven years.

• Choose a personal loan if you need a larger amount, want to build credit or need predictable payments. Only consider a payday loan for a true emergency you can fully repay on payday.

Summary generated by AI, verified by MoneyLion editors

MoneyLion offers a service to help you find personal loan offers. Based on the information you provide, you can get matched with offers for up to $50,000 from our top providers. You can compare rates, terms, and fees from different lenders and choose the best offer for you.

What Is a Payday Loan?

A payday loan is a small, short-term loan — typically $100 to $500 — that you repay in one payment on your next payday, usually within two to four weeks. According to the CFPB, payday loan APRs commonly run around 400%.

What Is a Personal Loan?

A personal loan is an installment loan from a bank, credit union or online lender. Loan amounts usually range from $1,000 to $50,000 and are repaid with fixed monthly payments over one to seven years. Personal loan APRs typically range from 6% to 36%, according to Federal Reserve data. 

How Each Loan Works, Step by Step

How a Payday Loan Works

1. You apply for a payday loan in person or online with proof of income and a bank account.

2. The lender approves you the same day, often without a credit check.

3. You receive $100 to $500 in cash or by direct deposit.

4. You write a postdated check or authorize an automatic debit for the loan amount plus fees.

5. The lender pulls the full balance from your account on your next payday, usually within two to four weeks.

How a Personal Loan Works

1. You compare lenders and check your rate with a soft credit pull.

2. You submit a full application for a personal loan with income, employment and credit details.

3. The lender runs a hard credit check and sets your APR based on your credit score.

4. You receive the funds via direct deposit, typically within one to five business days.

5. You repay the loan in fixed monthly payments over one to seven years. 

Payday Loan and Personal Loan Stats You Should Know

The average payday loan is about $375, according to the Pew Charitable Trusts. The CFPB reports that a typical two-week payday loan carries an APR near 400% and that about 80% of payday loans are rolled over or followed by another loan within 14 days. By comparison, the Federal Reserve reports an average personal loan APR of roughly 12% for a 24-month loan. 

Pros and Cons of Each Loan Type

Payday Loan Pros and Cons

Pros of a payday loan:

• Fast funding: You can often get cash the same day you apply.

• No credit check: Most payday lenders skip the hard credit pull.

• Simple approval: A paycheck and a bank account are usually enough.

Cons of a payday loan:

• Very high APR: The CFPB reports a typical APR near 400%.

• Short repayment window: The full balance is due within two to four weeks.

• Risk of a debt cycle: Most borrowers roll the loan over or take out a new one to cover the first.

👉 Pros and Cons of Payday Loans

Personal Loan Pros and Cons

Pros of a personal loan:

• Lower APR: Rates typically range from 6% to 36%, according to Federal Reserve data.

• Larger loan amounts: You can borrow $1,000 to $50,000 or more for bigger expenses.

• Predictable payments: Fixed monthly payments make budgeting easier.

Cons of a personal loan:

• Credit check required: Most lenders run a hard pull and set your rate based on your score.

• Slower funding: Approval and deposit can take one to five business days.

• Origination fees: Some lenders charge 1% to 8% of the loan amount upfront

👉 Pros and Cons of Personal Loans

Payday Loan vs. Personal Loan Side-by-Side

The bottom line?

• A payday loan is cheaper only if you repay it on your very next payday and never roll it over.

• Personal loans cost less overall because you pay interest at a lower rate, even over longer terms.

Not only are payday loans and personal loans offered for different amounts, but they are also structured quite differently. With a payday loan, you'll need to repay the funds you borrow by your next paycheck, or you'll incur extra rollover fees. With personal loans, repayment terms range from six months to as long as seven years, depending on the lender, your application and the amount of money you're borrowing. 

Another key difference is the interest rate you'll pay. Payday loan APRs are often north of 300%, whereas personal loan APRs usually max out at 36%. 

How Much Does a Payday Loan Cost vs. a Personal Loan?

APR refers to the amount you'll pay in interest to borrow money, plus any additional fees. 

With payday loans, you're borrowing money for a matter of weeks, not months or years.

Payday loans:

• Charge $10 to $30 for every $300 you borrow.

• That can annualize into a 400% APR, even if you're only paying less than $100 in fees on top of the loan principal.

Personal loans:

• Charge an interest rate over time.

• Often come with a separate origination fee of 1% to 10% of the loan amount.

Example: How Fees and Repayment Work on Personal Loans vs. Payday Loans

For a payday loan, say you need $500.

1. You'll borrow $500 from the payday loan lender.

2. For example, a $500 payday loan that charges a $75 fee for a two-week term works out to an APR of nearly 400%.

3. Your total repayment due by your next paycheck is $575.

4. If you have to push back the repayment, you'll be hit with a $75 rollover fee. 

For a personal loan of $500 with 20% APR and a 12-month term:

1. Factor in a 5% origination fee of about $25.

2. You make monthly payments of around $46.

3. You pay roughly $55 in total interest.

4. Your all-in cost is about $80 over the year.

That's comparable to the payday loan fee, but spread across 12 months instead of two weeks.

Don't Focus Only on APR

Ultimately, APR alone doesn't tell the full story. The true cost of borrowing depends on both the rinterest rate and how long you carry the debt.

• A payday loan's triple-digit APR can be manageable if you repay it quickly, but incredibly expensive if you roll it over.

• A personal loan's lower APR compounds over time, so the longer your term, the more you'll pay in total interest.

👉 Personal Loan Benefits: Advantages and Examples

Should You Pay Off a Loan All at Once or Over Time?

Here's a breakdown of your options:

Lump Sum Repayment

With a payday loan, you'll need to repay the entire amount you borrowed, plus fees, as a lump sum once you receive your next paycheck. If you can, great.

Rollover

If you can't, you'll have to roll over your payment, which means you'll be charged an additional fee, usually the same amount you originally paid to borrow.

For example, if you borrowed $500 and were charged a $75 fee, rolling over the loan once means you've now paid $150 in fees and still owe the original $500. 

Another Potential Concern With Payday Loans

Payday lenders usually require you to link the account that receives your paycheck so they can automatically debit the repayment once your paycheck clears.

You Don't Have Enough Money

If you don't have enough money in your account when the lender tries to collect repayment, you could be charged overdraft fees by both the lender and your bank. These snowballing fees are what make payday loans dangerous.

Collection Efforts

Plus, if you fall far enough behind on repaying a payday loan, the lender can sell your debt to a third-party collections agency, which will continue the effort of trying to secure your repayment. Not only is this stressful, but it also has negative consequences for your credit that can stay on your credit report for a few years.

👉 Payday Loan Alternatives

What To Consider With Personal Loans

While you may end up paying more in interest over time with a personal loan, the benefit is that you repay the funds with fixed monthly payments rather than a lump sum due within just two weeks of borrowing. This repayment structure is often easier to fit into your budget, which could reduce the risk of falling behind on payments. 

Plus, with a personal loan, you often have more options even if you're not able to repay the funds in time. Many lenders offer hardship programs, and borrowers who reach out when they realize they can't make a payment may be able to negotiate adjusted repayment terms that better fit their current financial situation, though it isn't guaranteed.

That's not to say there's no credit risk with a personal loan — lenders can still transfer your debt to collections if you go long enough without repaying, and you don't reach out to the lender to discuss your options.

When Does a Personal Loan Make More Sense Than a Payday Loan?

If you need to borrow money and you're trying to decide between a payday loan and a personal loan, you can use the following guidelines to help narrow down your choice.

Choose a personal loan if:

• You qualify for a lower APR.

• You need more than a few hundred dollars.

• You can manage fixed monthly payments.

• You want to build credit.

Only consider a payday loan if:

• It's a true emergency.

• You can repay in full with your next paycheck.

• No lower-cost options are available.

Also, keep in mind that payday loans and personal loans aren't your only options. You can also consider the following:

• Credit union payday alternative loans (PALs): PALs are similar to payday loans but are offered through credit unions, with APRs capped at 28% and an application fee of up to $20.

• Payment plans with providers: If you're considering a loan because you owe, you could also go directly to the source and see if you can negotiate a payment plan that's workable for your budget. For example, if you owe money to a landlord, hospital or utility company, contacting them to negotiate could help resolve a short-term cash flow dilemma.

• Family support: Depending on your relationship with your family, you could also consider asking a relative to lend you money to cover an emergency expense.

• Employer paycheck advance programs: Also called earned wage access (EWA) programs, these options, like MoneyLion Instacash®, let you use wages from your paycheck, based on eligibility, ahead of payday with 0% interest, though keep in mind that this isn't a loan.

Whichever option you choose, prioritize predictable payments, transparent costs and options that support your credit health in the long term. For most, this means avoiding payday loans — the fee cycles are short, but they stack up fast.

Final Take: Payday Loan vs Personal Loan

Payday loans offer quick access to cash, but they come at a steep price, and you’ll need to pay the money back quickly as one lump sum. With personal loans, you'll have more time to repay the funds you borrowed, and you’ll pay a more reasonable interest rate.

Before you decide on the right option for you, compare the total cost, including all fees, and make sure you know exactly how much you’re expected to pay and when.

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the main difference between a payday loan and a personal loan?

Payday loans have significantly higher APRs and require repayment in full by your next paycheck, whereas you can repay a personal loan in monthly installments over a longer period of time.

Is a payday loan or a personal loan easier to get?

A payday loan is easier to get. Most payday lenders skip the credit check and approve you based on income and a bank account. Personal loans require a credit check and usually a fair-to-good credit score.

Which loan is more affordable?

Making either a personal loan or a payday loan more affordable depends on how quickly you can repay it. Personal loans usually have lower interest rates than payday loans. You may end up paying less out of pocket with a payday loan if you don't have to roll over your repayment date.

Can you have a payday loan and a personal loan at the same time?

Yes. Nothing stops you from holding both at once if each lender approves you. Just remember that stacking loans raises your total monthly debt payments and can hurt your credit and budget.

Do payday loans build credit?

No. Most payday lenders do not report on-time payments to Equifax, Experian or TransUnion, so paying a payday loan back will not raise your credit score. 

Can payday loans hurt your credit?

Payday loans can hurt your credit if you don't repay them, and the lender sells your debt to a collection agency. This will result in a negative mark on your credit report, which can damage your credit score and remain there for a few years.

What credit score do you need for a personal loan?

Most personal loan lenders require a score of at least 580, and the best rates typically go to borrowers with scores of 670 or higher. Some online lenders work with lower scores but charge higher APRs.

Key Terms

• Annual percentage rate (APR): The yearly cost of borrowing, including interest and certain fees, shown as a % so you can compare loan costs more easily.

• Origination fee: A one-time lender fee charged for processing a personal loan, often 1% to 10% of the amount you borrow.

• Rollover fee: A fee charged when you extend a payday loan instead of repaying it on time, which can quickly raise your total borrowing cost.

• Lump-sum repayment: Paying back the full loan amount plus fees all at once, usually by your next paycheck with a payday loan.

• Installment loan: A loan repaid through fixed monthly payments over time, which is how most personal loans are structured.

Sources

• Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: What is an annual percentage rate (APR)?

• Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: What is an origination fee?

• Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: What is a rollover fee on a payday loan?

• Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: What is a payday loan?

• Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: What is a personal loan?

• Federal Trade Commission (FTC). "What To Know About Payday Loans."

• MyCreditUnion.gov. "Payday Alternative Loans."

• National Credit Union Administration (NCUA). 2024. "Permissible Loan Interest Rate Ceiling Extended."

Summary generated by AI, verified by MoneyLion editors

Melanie Grafil, CFHC™ contributed to the editing of this article.