The Emotional Cost of Debt: How It's Reshaping American Life

Over 50% of Americans have felt a sense of shame about going into debt, according to a 2026 MoneyLion survey. The irony is that it doesn't matter how the debt happened. A layoff, a medical emergency, anything that forces the decision rather than inviting it — the shame shows up even when the cause is outside of a person's control. The emotional weight of carrying debt can be just as difficult to manage as the financial burden itself.

What does the emotional weight impact? It affects everything from the guilt parents carry for their kids, relationship strains and other everyday financial decisions. A recent MoneyLion survey of 1,000 Americans ages 18 and older found that debt doesn't just impact finances, but it can also cause serious psychological and emotional tolls.

MoneyLion offers a service to help you find personal loan offers. Based on the information you provide, you can get matched with offers for up to $100,000 from our top providers. You can compare rates, terms, and fees from different lenders and choose the best offer for you.

Key Findings: The Numbers Behind the Guilt

• You're not the only one keeping your debt a secret. Forty-one percent of Americans — and a full half of everyone carrying debt — have hidden how much they actually owe from someone close to them. Women (46%) are more likely to hide debt than men (36%).

• At least 40% of parents have gone into debt so their kids wouldn't feel left out. For parents ages 25 to 34, that figure jumps to 50%. Moms are carrying more of that burden than dads: 45% vs. 35%. Being a “good parent” often comes with a financial cost.

• More than half of parents are quietly afraid their debt is going to follow their kids into adulthood. Fifty-two percent feel guilty about it, and 39% worry it could limit their kids' opportunities. Among parents under 35, that figure rises above 55%. Moms (25%) report guilt more often than dads (16%).

• Eighty-two percent of people believe going into debt for your children is sometimes acceptable. Only 12% say it's never okay. The guilt parents carry may be out of proportion to how others actually view their decisions.

• Debt doesn't just affect wallets — it affects how people see themselves. One in four people said they compare themselves to others and feel like they're falling behind, while 41% have hidden the true size of their debt from someone close to them.

How Debt Is Reshaping Adulthood

Carrying debt has real consequences on day-to-day life. It’s not only a financial burden, but it’s also delaying relationship milestones and affecting daily expenses and health.

Debt Drives Substantial Delays in Relationship Milestones

“Debt doesn’t drain bank accounts. It delays entire life chapters,” according to Andrew Lokenauth, money expert and owner of Fluent in Finance.

Lokenauth’s observations align with MoneyLion’s survey data:

• Over 30% of Americans put off getting married because of debt.

• Nearly 35% have delayed having children because of debt.

“Today, people in their late 30s are postponing marriage, skipping having kids or staying in jobs they hate because $30,000 in debt and the cost of change feels impossible,” Lokenauth said.

Debt also puts pressure on people who want to leave relationships but feel they can't afford to.

• Nearly 20% have stayed in a relationship because they couldn't afford to leave.

When Debt Eats Into Everyday Expenses

MoneyLion's survey found that debt isn't just affecting long-term goals — it's impacting people's ability to cover everyday expenses.

• Nearly 60% of Americans have relied on borrowing or credit to pay for groceries and household expenses.

• Over 40% have delayed or skipped medication because of cost concerns.

As a certified financial expert, to me, this number signifies that many are struggling for financial survival. If these same consumers aren’t able to pay off their credit card balances, then they may end up paying 20% to 24% interest on everyday necessities like food.

“When people skip medication to cover a minimum payment, they get sicker. When they skip therapy because they can't afford it, the anxiety builds. The stress becomes a cost of its own," Lokenauth said.

Debt’s Invisible Interest Rate

Carrying and thinking about debt hums in the background throughout your financial and personal life.

• More than half of Americans surveyed have felt shame about their debt.

• A little over 40% have hidden debt from a close family member.

• Over 35% are not at all comfortable discussing debt with their loved ones.

• Only 16% feel comfortable talking about debt with their close family members.

The numbers indicate that debt pushes individuals to remain silent, which can make it harder for people to seek support or break the cycle.

To combat some of that secrecy, Nathan Astle, a certified financial therapist on Psychology Today, recommends increasing financial transparency and accountability.

One way to do that is to have check-ins monthly regarding finances. Be sure to cover important financial accounts, including checking, savings, credit cards and investments. These conversations can be difficult, so it’s essential that parties take breaks when emotions run high.

Comparison Is the New Overspending

Keeping up with the Joneses has gained new momentum.

“Social media broke something in the American psyche. We've gone from keeping up with the Joneses next door to keeping up with thousands of strangers online, all at once, all day. I've talked about this with my 3+ million followers @FluentInFinance, and the feedback is clear: people feel ashamed of real, normal lives that don't look like a curated highlight reel,” Lokenauth said.

Wendy Molyneux, author of “Financial Trauma, Why Money Isn’t Just About Money,” said the same patterns appear in her work.

“The behavioral side of comparison is seen in lifestyle choices, social signaling and indebtedness. Cultural expectations can drive overspending, lifestyle inflation — moving the goalposts as income increases — and ‘keeping up with the Joneses’ patterns.”

This mentality of keeping up with a curated appearance often leads parents to overspend on their children.

• Nearly 40% of parents spend because they don't want their kids to feel left out.

This sentiment is also reshaping how many think about the American Dream.

• Almost half of those surveyed believe the American Dream isn’t achievable without going into debt.

“The emotional side of comparison affects how people judge their worth, progress or adequacy relative to others. This is where definitions of ‘success’ and tensions around the ‘American Dream’ live,” Molyneux said.

Lokenauth said there's a disconnect between the American Dream and what people see online.

“A huge chunk of those polished lifestyles online are financed by debt. The vacation was charged to a card. The car is leased. The kitchen renovation was a home equity line of credit (HELOC). The ‘American Dream’ used to mean building wealth over time. Now it means looking wealthy right now, even if it hollows out your financial future.”

4 Practical Moves That Quiet the Shame of Debt

The emotional pressure and shame of debt is real, but there are steps you can take to alleviate stress and improve your financial health over time.

1. Start Small

As a certified financial expert, I know that many people struggle with where to begin. It can feel like no matter what you do, nothing will make a meaningful difference.

Lokenauth sees this mentality with clients:

“In my 20 years in finance, the biggest mistake I've seen people make is trying to fix everything at once and giving up when they can't.”

Instead of trying to solve every financial problem, focus on a few small steps. For starters, ask your loved one if they would be willing to have a conversation about budgeting. As the conversation evolves, see if you can move toward other subjects like debt, savings and investing.

2. Start an Emergency Fund

To stop the debt cycle, you need a way to address unexpected expenses. Even if you’re in debt, it’s a good idea to start building an emergency fund.

The fund can start small. If you save $20 to $50 a month, you could accumulate $240 to $600 a year. One easy way to save is to automate your paycheck every two weeks to deposit funds into your savings account.

“Build a $500 to $1,000 emergency buffer,” Lokenauth said. “Just a small cushion that stops one unexpected expense from blowing up your entire budget.”

By having a buffer, you may be able to avoid payday loans and other high-interest borrowing options when unexpected medical bills, car repairs or other expenses arise.

3. Prioritize High-Interest Debt

If you're carrying high-interest debt, it’s a good idea to pay these accounts off first. Start by making a list of all your debts. You can then consider using the avalanche method:

• Make the minimum payment on all debts.

• Put any extra funds toward the balance with the highest interest rate.

• Repeat until that balance is paid off, then move to the next-highest rate.

Some may question whether it’s worth investing if you have outstanding high-interest debt. Lokenauth's view is straightforward:

“Focus on your highest-interest debt first, usually credit cards running at 20%+. Every dollar you put toward that is a guaranteed 20% return. No investment beats that."

4. Avoid Comparison Spending

As you're working on paying off your debts, it may be a good idea to take yourself off social media. Eliminating the source of your comparison may prevent you from falling into the temptation of buying something you don’t need.

Molyneux said approaching the process with self-compassion is important:

“It's important to exercise self-compassion while acknowledging the cultural pressures that have shaped the financial behavior and resolving to make small changes over time to change course.”

Lokenauth also suggested tracking spending for 30 days.

“Track every dollar for a month, no exceptions. Most people are stunned by what they find. It turns vague guilt into specific data, and once you see it clearly, you can fix it. Cut one category that surprised you. Just one. Small wins build momentum, and momentum is what actually gets people out of debt.”

Methodology

MoneyLion surveyed 1,000 Americans ages 18 and older from across the country between June 1 and June 4, 2026. Using PureSpectrum's survey platform, respondents answered 26 questions about debt and its impact on major life decisions, including marriage, children, housing, healthcare, spending habits, financial stress, social comparison and perceptions of the American Dream.

Photo credit: Rawpixel / iStock