If you’ve ever opened your credit report and found a collection account staring back at you, welcome to the club. Collections happen — medical bills slip through cracks, old credit cards resurface like ghosts, and that gym you visited twice apparently never forgot you existed.
The big, anxiety-inducing question people always ask is: will paying a collection actually raise your credit score?
The short answer is: maybe.
The longer answer: it depends on the type of credit scoring model, the age of the debt, and how the collection gets updated on your report.
Let’s break down what actually happens so you can plan your next move with a little more confidence and a lot less guessing.
Boost your credit! MoneyLion’s Credit Builder Plus membership has been proven to help more than half our members raise their score by up to 27 points within the first 60 days*. Get a credit builder loan reported to all 3 credit bureaus, no hard credit check required.
How credit scores treat collections
Credit scores are essentially risk meters. When an account lands in collections, it signals that a lender had to escalate things, and that history becomes part of how future lenders view you.
Here’s the important nuance: the biggest damage to your score usually happens when the account first becomes delinquent and then gets reported as a collection. Paying it later doesn’t magically erase that moment in time.
But some scoring models treat paid collections differently — in a good way. According to Experian, newer scoring models often ignore paid collections entirely.
That’s the start of the good news. Now for the rest.
Why paying a collection might raise your score
There are a few very real scenarios where paying a collection can help your score — sometimes immediately, sometimes gradually.
Newer scoring models stop counting paid collections
As noted above, newer scoring models like FICO 9, FICO 10, and the latest VantageScore systems drop paid collections from their formulas. If your lenders or apps use these newer models, paying the collection may lead to a score increase once the account updates.
Your overall credit profile could look less risky
Even if your score doesn’t jump, lenders often review reports manually. A paid collection usually looks better than an unpaid one, especially if you’re planning to apply for something big like a car loan or mortgage.
To build a stronger foundation while you’re cleaning up old debts, MoneyLion’s guide on how to build credit is a good place to start:
You might stop future problems before they start
Unpaid collections can be resold to other agencies. When that happens, the tradeline may update again, creating ongoing headaches. Paying the debt resolves the account and reduces the likelihood of new activity being added to your report.
Why paying a collection might not raise your score
As fun as it would be to watch your score shoot up the moment you hit “submit payment,” that’s not always how the math works.
Older scoring models still count paid collections
Many mortgage lenders still rely on older FICO versions that don’t differentiate between paid and unpaid collections. In those systems, the fact that the debt went to collections at all is what matters, not whether you later paid it.
The damage may already be “baked in”
If the collection is several years old, your score may have already absorbed the hit and begun to recover naturally. Paying an older collection may not change things immediately, even though it improves your file long-term.
Collections stay on your report for up to seven years
Paying a collection updates the status, but the account itself doesn’t disappear unless the collector agrees to remove it. Which brings us to…
What about pay-for-delete?
A pay-for-delete agreement is when a collection agency agrees to remove the account entirely from your credit report after payment. It’s the closest thing to a clean slate.
A few things to keep in mind:
- Agencies are not obligated to offer this.
- Some major creditors prohibit it.
- If offered, it must always be in writing.
You should never pay an extra fee for deletion; that’s a red flag.
Even if deletion isn’t possible, paying the debt still prevents new updates and can strengthen your creditworthiness when lenders manually review your report.
Should you pay the collection?
Here’s a quick framework to help you decide.
Paying usually makes sense when:
- The collection is recent
- The debt is verified and accurate
- You’re planning to apply for new credit soon
- You want to prevent ongoing collection activity
- It’s a medical collection that newer scoring models ignore once paid
Paying may not move your score much when:
- The debt is old
- Future lenders use older scoring models
- You’re near the seven-year reporting limit
Even in those cases, resolving the debt still gives you a cleaner report and better odds with lenders who manually review applications.
How to approach paying a collection wisely
Before sending money, take these steps to protect yourself and maximize any potential score benefit.
Verify that the debt is accurate
Under the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, you have the right to request verification. Collections can contain errors — wrong amounts, wrong dates, or even debts that aren’t yours.
Negotiate the amount
Collectors often accept debt settlements. Just be sure you understand whether the updated status will read as “paid in full” or “settled for less.” Both resolve the debt, but they may be reported differently.
Always get agreements in writing
Payment plans, settlements, pay-for-delete — none of it counts unless you have written documentation. This protects you if reporting issues arise later.
Build credit while you resolve collections
Paying collections is only one part of the puzzle. Your can potentially improve your credit score if you pair the payoff with good habits going forward:
- Make on-time payments consistently
- Keep credit utilization low
- Maintain older accounts to lengthen your credit history
If you’re wondering how long credit repair takes or what progress looks like over time, MoneyLion’s guide on how long credit takes to recover is a helpful companion read.
So … will paying collections raise your score?
It can — depending on the scoring model and the account. Newer scoring systems often ignore paid collections completely, which gives many people a real score boost once the update goes through. Older models won’t reward you as dramatically, but paying still improves how lenders perceive you and prevents future problems.
Think of it like finally cleaning out the junk drawer. Your house doesn’t suddenly become an Architectural Digest spread, but the overall picture gets better, clearer, and a lot less stressful.
