Costco vs. Sam's Club: Which Store Has the Best Value on Little Luxuries?
Treating yourself has gotten harder. Between rent and grocery receipts, a $20 sweater or a candle that smells like a five-star hotel feels like a serious splurge, so you’d better get your money’s worth.
Costco and Sam’s Club are the usual suspects for bulk savings, and both will happily hand you a free sample on the way past. But when it comes to the stuff you buy just because it makes you happy, the two clubs play very different games.
Check Out: 5 Smart Costco Buys for Homeowners That Elevate Any Room
For You: 7 Low-Risk Accounts Proven To Grow Your Money Up to 13x Faster
The real question isn’t which store is cheaper. It’s whether you want the lowest price or the feeling of a better product. Depending on what’s in your cart, each club has a clear edge. Here’s how they stack up.
Don't Wait: The Best Sam's Club Deals To Grab Now For Fall
Clothing: Costco Quality vs. Sam's Club Price
Costco pick: Kirkland Signature ladies' lightweight jogger ($14.99)
Sam’s Club pick: Member's Mark women's travel jogger ($12.98)
Kirkland Signature clothing has developed a genuine cult following, and stylish and savvy Costco shoppers frequently replace entire wardrobes with Kirkland items, praising the quality relative to price. The aforementioned Kirkland Signature ladies' lightweight jogger as well as men's dress shirts and cashmere sweaters consistently earn five-star reviews for materials and construction.
Sam's Club's Member's Mark clothing is solid but leans more basics-focused and often slightly lower scores where reviews are involved. Member's Mark products tend to be priced slightly lower than Kirkland, so if budget is the priority, Sam's edges it out. However, if you're shopping for something that feels like a luxury item at a non-luxury price, Costco might be the move.
Beauty Products: Sam's Club Variety vs. Costco’s Selected Picks
Costco pick: Beauty of Joseon glow serum propolis + niacinamide ($29.99)
Sam’s Club pick: Olay super serum with vit C, E, niacinamide, collagen ($47.98 for 2-pack, price per unit $23.99)
Both Kirkland Signature and Member's Mark cover beauty and personal care categories, but Member's Mark slightly edges out the competition with over 600 products to Kirkland's roughly 300, according to Yahoo! Life. Of course, this is a broad category that includes everything from haircare to wellness products, and the pricing difference is minimal, if anything, between the two brands.
This means when weighing your options, variety may be what spices up your choices. Especially when you consider that Sam's Club also stocks name-brand prestige beauty through its Sephora partnership in select locations.
Accessorize Yourself: Sam's Club Has the Price Advantage
Costco pick: Round brilliant 0.25 ctw VS2 clarity, color diamond band ($849)
Sam’s Club pick: vintage diamond band in 14K gold ($549)
Sam's Club Member's Mark products tend to run cheaper than their Kirkland Signature counterparts across most categories, but is true for the shiny objects as well? As it turns out, yes.
Both stores carry jewelry, handbags and high-end, luxurious accessories, but Sam's typically undercuts Costco by a few dollars per item with a wider range of options.
Seasonal Decorations: Sam's Club Offers More on a Budget
Costco pick: Fitz & Floyd pumpkin serving bowl with lid ($39.99)
Sam’s Club pick: Member's Mark pre-lit rotating shimmer pumpkin ($13.91)
Costco's home section is genuinely one of the best places to shop for elevated decor at reasonable prices. That means autumnal throws and rugs, holiday-themed picture frames and candles and other seasonal items that regularly get mistaken for much more expensive finds.
This is not to say Sam’s Club brings nothing to the table in this category, as it offers many seasonal items, but Costco's buyers are known for curating a selection with an eye toward perceived quality. While Sam's Club offers patio furniture, decorations and seasonal items at slightly lower prices, the selection is narrower and less curated.
The Bottom Line
Costco is the better bet when you want something that looks and feels like a splurge. Sam’s Club wins when the price is the point and you want more options for less.
If you’re trying to treat yourself without wrecking the budget, the smartest move may be splitting the difference: Costco for the throw blanket, and Sam’s for the shimmer pumpkin.
Editor’s note: Prices and availability are subject to change.
This article was provided by MoneyLion.com for informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial, legal or tax advice.
More From MoneyLion: