MoneyLion
Nov 3, 2026

7 Fall Grocery Staples You Should Buy at Costco Before They Sell Out

Pumpkin season waits for no one. Grab these must-have Costco fall grocery finds before they disappear from shelves.
Written by Caitlyn Moorhead
|
Edited by Zuri Anderson
7 Fall Grocery Staples You Should Buy at Costco Before They Sell Out

Costco's seasonal items seem to run on a treasure-hunt model, which means there are limited quantities, one-time buys, no restocks and you simply have to scavenge for all the fall fan favorites.

Unlike regular grocery stores where you can grab something next week, Costco seasonal items are truly first come, first served.

Trending Now: 14 Best Things To Buy at Costco Under $25 This Fall

For You: 13 Subtly Genius Things All Wealthy People Do With Their Money — That You Should Do, Too

These seven fall staples offer real value (sometimes saving you 30% to 70%) compared to specialty retailers. However, it's best to shop now, as Costco's fall season is short, so make it count when you add to cart. 

Explore More: The Best Costco Buys To Grab Now For Fall

  • Price: $6.80 (per pie)

Costco's legendary pumpkin pie has been a fall fixture since 1987. It comes in at 58 ounces under $7, and feeds a crowd for less than you'd pay for two fancy pumpkin spice lattes. This pie has a high sell-out likelihood as it is the first thing to disappear from Costco’s bakery section.

  • Price: $9.07 (for a dozen)

Flaky, all-butter pastry with gooey filling, these Kirkland Signature Caramel Apple Strudel Bites are great to warm up and serve with a scoop of vanilla ice cream. One box gives you 12 individually portioned bites perfect for breakfast or dessert (which bakes out to about 76 cents a pop). These are relatively new and already a cult favorite, so don’t sleep on them. 

  • Price: $18.15 (for 2.5 pounds)

At roughly $9 per pound, these beat specialty retailers by 60%. You'll use them on charcuterie boards, in salads, and yes, just straight from the bag. Pecans are a fall harvest crop, so once Costco's seasonal allocation sells out, the Kirkland Signature Praline Pecans are gone until next year.

  • Price: $14.74 (for 33.8 ounces)

Nothing beats 100% pure, Grade A amber, USDA organic Kirkland Signature Organic Pure Maple Syrup. This is sourced directly from Quebec producers and costs roughly 44 cents per ounce, which undercuts specialty maple syrup by a wide margin. Though this product doesn’t sell out as dramatically as pies, it does sell steadily through fall and winter, so supplies can take a hit.

  • Price: $10.20 (2-count, 24-ounces)

Restaurant-quality comfort food at warehouse prices makes this Panera Autumn Squash Soup a bestseller on Costco's Same-Day Delivery platform because it actually tastes like the real thing. Fall comfort-food season means high demand, so grab extra to freeze.

  • Price: $10.20 (12-count, 4-ounces)

Creamy, indulgent Australian Noosa Whole Milk Yoghurt comes in seasonal flavors like apple pie and vanilla bean. Fall varieties are limited-edition, so you literally can't get these any other time of year. Stock up in the Costco dairy aisle now.

  • Price: $4.87 (per pound)

Perfect for fall game days, quick weeknight dinners or freezing for later. Costco’s Kirkland Signature Beef Chili is rich and hearty, and it tastes as if it simmered for hours. Buy multiple containers and freeze them to last through winter. 

Editor's note: Prices and availability are subject to change.

This article was provided by MoneyLion.com for informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial, legal or tax advice.

More From MoneyLion:


Caitlyn Moorhead
Written by
Caitlyn Moorhead
Caitlyn Moorhead has written content for a variety of businesses and publications. She specializes in SEO content writing with a focus in finance. Her pieces cover everything from bank reviews to saving money tips. Caitlyn graduated from Central Michigan University cum laude with a BA in public relations and political science, with concentrations in journalism, communication and broadcasting.
Edited by
Zuri Anderson
Zuri is an editor with over 8 years of digital content and news experience. When she's not managing her freelance writers, voraciously editing copy and coming up with engaging stories, she's catching up on her favorite shows, books, movies and video games.