Should You Save for Retirement or Buy a House?
Pursuing big milestones like buying a house and saving for retirement can put you in a better financial position, but which one should you do first? Unfortunately these days it's usually a choice between one or the other.
On one hand, buying a house can give you stability and build equity over time with mortgage payments. However, you can get higher returns if you put your money in the right assets, and moving along nicely with your nest egg can reduce financial stress during your retirement years. It's important to consider your personal situation and goals, and these ideas can help you make the right decision.
Here are the biggest considerations in making your decision.
Earning Enough? The Living Wage Required for a 4-Person Family in All 50 States
Don’t Delay: Start Growing Your Net Worth With Smarter Tracking
Timing Plays a Big Role
Frank Grimes, president and owner of Associates Home Loan of Florida Inc., said people who want to buy a home in the next five to 10 years should prioritize that objective while understanding that retirement savings is a long-term game.
"Timing will likely be your biggest concern," Grimes said. "The typical decision to buy a home is made for the medium term (five to 10 years) and retirement savings rely almost entirely on long-term compounding. Therefore, your age, where you are in your career and your current level of financial stability should help determine what goal you need to focus on at this point."
Even if you are prioritizing a house, Grimes still recommends saving for retirement, even if you don't max out your 401(k) plan.
"You should also think about opportunity cost," he said. "Avoid delaying retirement contributions — especially if your employer is offering a match, as it reduces long-term returns. Even making smaller contributions earlier in life can significantly enhance your future wealth."
Assess Your Personal Situation
Louisiana real estate agent Erin Hybart suggested analyzing your financial profile first and using that as a framework for setting realistic goals on homeownership and saving for retirement. She also recommended assessing your lifestyle preferences before committing to a mortgage.
"Start by looking at your current savings, income and debt," she said. "If you don't have an emergency fund or any retirement savings started, that's a red flag. But if you're renting in an expensive market and plan to stay in one place for a while, buying a home could help stabilize your costs and build equity over time. Also, think about how flexible you want to be. Owning a home ties you to one place, while saving for retirement gives you more long-term freedom."
She emphasized that you shouldn't pause retirement account contributions while saving up for a house. You can do both, but it is important to set realistic expectations and know how much you should store for retirement.
"If homeownership is a near-term goal, focus on building a solid down payment while still putting something toward retirement. Prioritize based on your timeline, but try not to pause retirement savings entirely. If you can get an employer match on a 401(k), take it. That's free money," Hybart said.
She also recommended cutting subscriptions, eating out less and paying off high-interest debt to free up more space in your budget.
Get Creative With Your Housing
Looking to buy a traditional house can make homeownership feel less attainable due to high housing costs (such as taxes and HOA fees) and maintenance expenses that make the total price of housing far more than your mortgage. Hybart's solution for people who want homeownership but feel priced out is to consider alternative housing options like tiny homes.
"If you're buying, consider creative solutions like tiny homes, ADUs [accessory dwelling units] or duplexes. Living small or generating rental income can help offset costs and make ownership more sustainable. Some buyers are also looking into multigenerational homes or co-buying with friends or family to make things work," Hybart said. You can build or buy a tiny home for less than $100,000, depending on its size.
Condominiums and co-ops more appropriately sized to households of one or two people can quickly put homeownership back in reach compared to the traditional standalone house with its own yard.
This article was provided by MoneyLion.com for informational purposes only and should not be construed as financial, legal, or tax advice.
More From MoneyLion: