Is It Better to Buy a New or Used Car?

Written by
Is It Better to Buy a New or Used Car

New or used? It’s the age-old car conundrum. With the average cost of a new car soaring to $48,808 as of June, many drivers are considering their options. While that shiny new car smell can be tempting, is it the best choice for your wallet? Read on to explore the world of car buying along with the pros and cons of both new and used vehicles to help you decide what fits your needs and budget.

Advantages of buying a new car

Besides the sheer joy of driving a car off the lot that has never known the woes of a previous owner, there are tons of other perks to buying a new car. Let’s cruise into a few of them.  

1. Reliability and warranty coverage

New cars offer the assurance of reliability, with their fresh-off-the-line status and modern components. It’s like setting off on a road trip in a car that’s just had a full check-up. New cars generally come with warranties that provide peace of mind. Warranties act as a safety net, protecting you against unexpected repair costs. It’s like having a safety buffer against those surprise breakdowns and frequent visits to the mechanic.

2. Lower interest rates

Financing a new car purchase often comes with the perk of a lower interest rate. This financial favor can lead to more wallet-friendly monthly payments. It’s like catching a sale at your favorite store — you get the product you want but at a better price. Over the life of the auto loan, lower interest rates can result in significant savings, leaving you with more cash in your pocket.

3. Latest features and technology advancements

New cars are the cream of the automotive crop. They’re the VIPs of the roadways. They don’t just roll off the production line…they sashay with the latest technological advancements in tow. 

Think advanced safety features, fuel efficiency that would make a marathon runner jealous, and connectivity options so smooth, they could moonlight as a master of ceremonies at a tech awards show. And yes, let’s not forget, all this top-of-the-line goodness means fewer breakdowns too, which translates to less unexpected pit stops in your journey of life.

4. Customization options

When you buy a new car, you can customize it to your heart’s content. You can handpick specific features and options that align with your preferences and needs. This level of customization ensures that your vehicle isn’t just a mode of transportation; it becomes an extension of your personality and lifestyle.

Disadvantages of buying a new car

When considering purchasing a new car, it’s important to weigh both the advantages and disadvantages. While new cars offer numerous benefits, such as reliability and advanced features, they also come with some drawbacks. 

1. Higher upfront cost

New cars may give you that new car smell, but they can also give your wallet a workout. With their substantial price tags and the added expense of registration, insurance, and taxes, it’s like dining at a fancy restaurant — a great experience, but your bank account feels the pinch.

2. Depreciation and potential negative equity

A new car depreciates faster than ice cream melts on a hot summer day. If you decide to sell it soon after buying, you might find yourself in a financial pickle. A new car depreciates up to 11% as soon as you drive it off the lot.

3. Steep insurance premiums

New cars are shiny and exciting, but they can also attract higher insurance premiums. It’s like buying a designer outfit — you look good, but the dry cleaning bill hurts. Your car might turn heads, but your insurance statement will, too.

4. Limited choices 

When you’re shopping for a new car, finding the perfect match can sometimes be a bit challenging. You might need to make compromises or patiently wait for your ideal vehicle to become available.

5. Initial quality concerns 

While new cars are generally reliable, there can be occasional minor issues in the early stages of ownership that might require visits to the dealership to ensure everything runs smoothly.

Advantages of buying a used car

While the allure of a new car is undeniable, there are distinct advantages to opting for a  used one. 

1. Cost savings

Used cars offer a substantial advantage when it comes to cost savings. They are typically more affordable than new vehicles, making them an attractive option for budget-conscious buyers. Affordability extends beyond the initial purchase price, as used cars often come with lower taxes and reduced depreciation rates. 

2. Reduced risk of hidden fees

Purchasing a used car can shield you from some of the hidden charges associated with new cars. New vehicles often come with destination charges, premiums for the latest features, and additional expenses that can significantly increase the overall cost. With a used car, you can enjoy a more transparent and predictable pricing structure without financial surprises.

3. Easier negotiation

Buying a used car often involves negotiation. Sellers of used cars are generally more open to haggling over the price and other terms. This flexibility allows buyers to potentially secure a better deal and tailor the purchase to their budget. 

4. Lower insurance costs

Used cars typically have lower insurance premiums. Because the value of the vehicle is usually less than that of a new car, insurance companies often offer more affordable coverage options. This can result in significant savings on insurance costs over time, contributing to the overall affordability of owning a used vehicle.

Save up to 40% on auto insurance* by turning on Driver Score, a program that measures your safe driving habits, such as your speed, braking, and acceleration.

*Actual discounts and insurer participation vary by state. Any potential offers are based on your driving behavior and are at insurers’ discretion and subject to their review. Not all drivers will qualify for a discount. Potential savings listed are based on the program goals.

Activate Driver Score!

5. Lower Registration Fees

Registering a used car often incurs lower fees compared to new cars, depending what state you live in. This could reduce the immediate financial burden and lead to long-term savings. Lower registration fees mean more money in your pocket, allowing you to allocate your resources to other important aspects of car ownership. 

Disadvantages of buying a used car

Although a used car may seem like a good option, there are also some disadvantages of buying a used car you should consider.

1. Potential hidden problems

Purchasing a used car carries the risk of encountering hidden issues or undisclosed problems. There was a prior owner, and you don’t always know how well they maintained the car or what their driving style was. These issues can range from mechanical problems to a history of accidents. As a buyer, you might not immediately spot these issues, and it could lead to unexpected and potentially costly surprises after the purchase. 

2. Limited or no warranty

Unlike new cars that often come with warranties that cover repair costs for a certain period, used cars usually lack this safety net. This means that if your used car encounters any issues or breakdowns shortly after purchase, you’ll likely have to foot the bill for repairs. 

3. Higher maintenance and repair costs

As cars age, they tend to require more frequent maintenance and repair work. This increased need for attention can result in higher overall expenses for the owner. Imagine taking care of an aging pet. They often need more visits to the vet, and these visits can add up over time.

4. Potential for higher fuel costs

Older used cars sometimes guzzle more gas compared to newer, more efficient models. It’s similar to having a phone with a battery that drains super quickly. You’ll find yourself at the charging station (or gas pump) more often.

5. Higher mileage 

Used cars often come with more miles on the odometer. This can be a bit like adopting an older dog — it might not have as much pep in its step, and you might have to deal with more health issues down the road. In the case of cars, that means more wear and tear.

Factors to consider when deciding between buying a new or used car

When deciding whether to purchase a new car or a used one, you should consider your budget, how long you want to own the car, and financing options.

1. Budget and financial considerations

Your budget is the key player in this decision. New cars tend to come with higher price tags, while used cars are generally more budget-friendly. Consider what you can comfortably afford without straining your finances.

2. Long-term plans and desired ownership period

Think about your plans with the vehicle. If you plan to keep it for a long time and value its reliability, a new car might be the way to go. But if you anticipate changing vehicles relatively frequently, a used car could be a more practical choice.

3. Personal preferences and lifestyle

Your personal preferences and lifestyle play a significant role in choosing the right car. Think about  your daily commute, family size, and the type of driving you do. If you value the latest tech, safety features, and a warranty, a new car might be appealing. But if you’re more budget-conscious and don’t mind a slightly older model, a used car can offer good value.

4. Available financing options

New cars often come with low-interest financing, like scoring a 0% interest rate on a credit card. Used cars might not have those flashy deals, but they can potentially save you money overall, depending on the rate you get. The higher your credit score, the better the rate. If you have bad credit, you may not qualify for a pricey new car.

5. Costs for repair and maintenance

Don’t forget to factor in the costs of repairs and maintenance. New cars typically require less immediate maintenance and come with warranties. Used cars may have lower upfront costs but could potentially require more maintenance and repairs overall. Research the reliability and maintenance history of specific models to make an informed choice.

The right ride for you

When it comes to choosing between a new and used car, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. 

Many factors are at play, from your budget and plans to your style and financing options. 

There’s no right or wrong choice here — it’s all about what suits you best. New cars offer the latest and greatest, while used cars have unique charm and affordability. Your decision should align with your lifestyle and preferences, just like picking the perfect playlist for a road trip.

Explore your options, weigh those factors, and choose the car that feels like the perfect fit for your journey. Whether it’s a new ride or a trusty used one, it’s all about making your driving experience as enjoyable as possible. 


How much money can I save if I buy a used car instead of a new one?

The savings from buying a used car instead of a new one depend on factors like the specific car, age, and mileage, but you could potentially save thousands of dollars upfront because of lower depreciation.

Will insurance cost more for a new car?

Yes, insurance premiums are typically higher for new cars because they have higher replacement and repair costs. Insurance rates vary based on many factors.

How do I determine the value of a used car?

You can estimate a used car’s value by considering factors like make, model, year, mileage, condition, and local market demand, using resources like Kelley Blue Book. Getting a prepurchase inspection by a mechanic can also help assess its worth and condition.

Sign Up
Sign Up

How much would you like to borrow?

Compare rates and get personalized offers.

It’s fast, free and won’t affect your credit score.

Sign Up