How to Switch Car Insurance Companies

How to Switch Car Insurance Companies

If your premiums are too high or the deductibles are causing financial worry, you can switch car insurance companies. Other reasons to consider switching insurance companies? Whether you’re moving to a different state, you’re adding a teen driver to your policy, or you found a better car insurance offer, switching providers can be a smart choice. When you switch insurance providers, you’ll want to ensure the coverage overlaps so you’re not left unprotected. Read on for how to switch car insurance companies with tips to make it simple and easy.

6 easy steps to switch car insurance companies

Switching car insurance companies takes six steps, from evaluating the current policy to updating your vehicle registration. Here’s what you want to consider.

Step 1: Evaluate your current policy

Start by reviewing your existing policy to understand the details of your coverage, including deductibles, premiums, and additional benefits. Check whether there is an early termination fee. Then, search for better options. 

Step 2: Research and compare quotes

Consider factors such as coverage options, customer reviews, and prices. You can compare insurance quotes online. Be sure to compare insurance policies that offer similar coverage to what you currently have or are more comprehensive. 

Consider what car insurance is best for your family and current risks. You can get car insurance quotes online to make comparison easier.

The main types of auto insurance are full coverage car insurance, comprehensive car insurance, and liability car insurance. Look at the policy type and total coverage, including any exclusions. 

If you’re also looking for ways to save on car insurance, MoneyLion can help!  Save up to 40% on auto insurance* by turning on Driver Score, a program that measures your safe driving habits, such as your speed, braking, and acceleration.

*Actual discounts and insurer participation vary by state. Any potential offers are based on your driving behavior and are at insurers’ discretion and subject to their review. Not all drivers will qualify for a discount. Potential savings listed are based on the program goals.

Activate Driver Score!

Step 3: Notify your current insurer

When you contact your current car insurer, check for cancellation fees or penalties, which will vary depending on your policy terms. If there are high cancellation fees and penalties, you can wait until the current contract ends to transfer car insurance companies. 

Step 4: Purchase your new car insurance policy

When purchasing a new auto insurance policy, it’s essential to ensure that it meets your requirements regarding coverage, deductibles, and premiums. Check for exclusions and thoroughly understand policy limitations to avoid unpleasant surprises like exclusions in the future.

Then, coordinate with your new insurance provider to set an appropriate start date for your policy, ensuring that there is no lapse in coverage. This can be on the first of the month or any other date that ensures continuous coverage. 

Search hundreds of insurers and find savings in seconds. Plus get free support to help you make the switch. See offers!

Step 5: Cancel your old car insurance policy 

When you’re ready to cancel, you must contact your current insurance provider to cancel your policy formally. Provide it with the necessary information and any documentation required. Depending on the policy, the cancellation may take effect immediately or at the end of the current billing period. 

Step 6: Update your vehicle registration and insurance information

Once your new policy takes effect and the old one is canceled, the final step, in some states, is updating vehicle registration and insurance information. To update your vehicle registration, submit a form and supporting documents to your state’s Department of Motor Vehicles. This typically includes your policy number and proof of insurance. You’ll also need to provide documentation to your new auto insurance company. 

Why would you switch car insurance companies?

Switching car insurance companies can help you find better coverage options, more competitive rates, improved customer service, or a combination of these factors. It allows you to take advantage of available options or special offers and potentially save money.

Five common scenarios where you might switch car insurance companies are:

  • You’re adding a new driver to the family policy, and another car insurance company has better rates or coverage.
  • You’re moving to a different state where your current auto insurance provider doesn’t operate.
  • You want to upgrade insurance policies from liability insurance to full coverage car insurance.
  • Your current insurance premiums or deductibles are too high. 
  • You’re unhappy with the auto insurance provider’s customer service.

If you’re adding a teen driver to your auto insurance policy, policies that are best for young drivers or high-risk drivers may be a better choice for your family. 

When is the right time to switch car insurance companies?

Several indicators can help you determine the right time to switch. These include unaffordable premiums, unsatisfactory customer service experiences, changes in your driving habits or circumstances, or finding better deals with other insurance. 

In some cases, outside factors like a move or a new driver in the family will force the situation and make you take immediate action. In other cases, you might research companies for some time before switching to a better offer. In either case, the steps above can help make the transition smooth. 

What to do if you have difficulty switching car insurance companies 

If you encounter difficulties switching car insurance companies, contact your state’s insurance department or regulatory authority for assistance. You can find contact information for all state insurance departments here. It can provide guidance, resolve disputes, and ensure your rights as a consumer are protected. 

Choosing the best auto insurer

Choosing an insurance provider that offers exceptional coverage and great customer service when you need it can be an important step to protect your family. By researching and planning, you can secure the right insurance for your needs. And with the steps above, switching auto insurers at any time is easy. Once you’ve got a new policy, learn when not to file an insurance claim to keep premiums low and protect your coverage. 


How much time should I give my current insurer before switching?

How much time you give your current auto insurer depends on the policy and the car insurer’s cancellation policy. Aim to give 30 days’ notice, at a minimum. If you paid in full for six months or a year, you might not get a refund for unused coverage. In some cases, if you cancel your policy within the first term or early, you may be entitled to a refund.

Can I switch car insurance in the middle of my policy term?

You can change car insurance anytime, but the current insurance provider might charge cancellation or early termination fees. 

Will I receive a refund if I switch car insurance during my policy term?

Whether you receive a refund when you switch car insurance during your policy term depends on the auto insurer’s policies. If you switch insurance companies, you may be entitled to a refund. Depending on your insurer, you may have to pay a cancellation fee.

Sign Up
Sign Up

Fast, interest-free advances anytime

Get Instacash advances up to $500 for everyday expenses or life’s surprises. There’s no credit check, no monthly fee, and no interest.

Sign Up